November 17, 2026
F
Filmmaker Commentary
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Film
  • TV
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Film
  • TV
Podcast

FMC 238 : The Smashing Machine Directed by Benny Safdie

March 12, 2026
Listen on Apple Spotify YouTube
Listen to this episode
Your browser does not support the audio element.
Also on Apple Spotify YouTube

This episode dives deep into Benny Safdie’s “The Smashing Machine,” exploring how a film starring Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, lauded at the Venice Film Festival for its raw portrayal of UFC fighter Mark Kerr, faced an unexpected box office outcome despite being an A24 release. Reginald Titus Jr. and Casey G. Smith unpack the film’s unusual financial performance, Johnson’s transformative acting, and the broader context of how audiences respond to actor-driven dramas versus genre expectations, all while discussing major industry news and HBO’s uncertain future.

What We Cover

  • The surprising box office results of “The Smashing Machine” (2025), with a budget of $40 million and a worldwide gross of only $21 million.
  • Dwayne Johnson’s profound physical and vocal transformation into Mark Kerr, raising questions about actor recognition and film reception.
  • Comparative analysis of fighting films like “The Wrestler” and their budgetary considerations versus box office success.
  • The critical reception of “The Smashing Machine” at festivals versus its commercial performance with general audiences.
  • The significant $2.8 billion termination fee paid to Netflix by Paramount during the proposed Warner Bros. Discovery acquisition battle.
  • Controversies surrounding “Scream 7” and the broader implications of actors’ public statements on film productions.

Key Moments

  • 0:56 — Reginald and Casey react to the disappointing box office numbers for “The Smashing Machine,” prompting a discussion on industry expectations.
  • 1:41 — The hosts compare the film’s performance to other fighting dramas and consider whether Dwayne Johnson’s drastically altered appearance played a role.
  • 4:39 — An in-depth breakdown of the Warner Bros. Discovery acquisition saga, detailing Netflix’s exit and Paramount’s substantial termination fee.
  • 8:26 — A summary of critical feedback for the film, which praised Johnson’s performance but found the storyline somewhat repetitive, contributing to its commercial flop status.

Gear & Films Mentioned

  • The Smashing Machine (2025)
  • The Wrestler (2008)
  • Magazine Dreams
  • Surviving the Game (1994)
  • Colors (1988)
  • Scream 7
  • House of the Dragon
  • Jungle Cruise
  • Looper
  • The Fly
  • Earth Girls Are Easy
  • HBO
  • A24
  • Paramount
  • Netflix
  • Warner Bros. Discovery
  • YouTube
  • Vizio
  • Roku
  • Zumo
  • Tubi

Listener Questions

  • How did “The Smashing Machine,” a film with Dwayne Johnson and festival praise, struggle so much at the box office?
  • What factors determine whether an audience embraces an actor in a radically different role or prefers their established persona?
  • What are the wider implications of recent corporate consolidations and controversies within the entertainment industry, particularly for streaming services like HBO, which Reginald and Casey frequently discuss on Filmmaker Commentary?

Full Transcript

Read the full transcript

Full Episode Transcript

This episode of Filmmaker Commentary Benny Safdie's "The Smashing Machine," analyzing its box office performance, critical reception, unique casting, and broader themes of addiction and identity, while also covering current entertainment news and what the hosts have been watching.

Opening Discussion and Box Office Performance

Reginald Titus Jr.: Filmmaker Commentary, episode 238. Welcome to Filmmaker Commentary, where we cover movies with commentaries from directors who take the time to record them on Blu-ray and DVDs. We also give our detailed insights, so look out for spoilers. We discuss the latest in showbiz news along with movies and TV shows that we've been watching. So, join Reginald Titus Jr., that's me, and KCG Smith, that's me, every week here on Filmmaker Commentary. Welcome to another episode of Filmmaker Commentary. I'm Reginald Titus Jr. I'm joined with KCG Smith. Welcome back, sir.

Casey G. Smith: Good to be back, sir.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And today we're talking about The Smashing Machine, uh, directed by Benny Safdie. Hopefully, I'm saying his last name correctly. Uh, 2025, and this is an, this is an A24 film in it. Yep. A24. Um, wow, The Smashing Machine. What was the box office and budget for this film?

Casey G. Smith.: Ladies and gentlemen, please take a seat. Okay. It's box office a little shocking, especially considering this is a film starring Dwayne The Rock Johnson. So, on a budget of $40 million, The Smashing Machine came in at just $21 million worldwide.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Ooh, $21 million on a $40 million budget. Out of the $21 million, um, how much was that at the US versus the rest of the world? Did it say?

Casey G. Smith: US and Canada, that's almost right right half, it's a little over 11 and a half million. Well, just under 11 and a half million in the US and Canada. That is sad.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. That is a big L.

Casey G. Smith: So part of me wonders a little bit about just if there's like not an interest in general in fighting films where people are fighting and battling because um, our girl uh, Sydney Sweeney had a fight movie come out called I think Christine or something like that, where she was playing a female boxer that apparently didn't do well at all either.

Reginald Titus Jr.: I think, I guess it's in the context of the fighting. So if it's a, if it's um, about a real person that people know about, usually people come out to support it, usually. Um, when it's like an obscure person that is known, but known only in that community, that could be hit or miss. But when you have someone that crosses over, usually people come out to see it like a Mike Tyson or a Bruce Lee or whatever, you know.

Casey G. Smith: Sure.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Um, this one surprised me because this will, this came out during the time when we were kind of taking our break, um, from the, from the episodes, and I wanted to talk about it a little bit because I, I actually expected this to at least do 100 million at the box office, at least.

Casey G. Smith: Same.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And when I hear a $40 million budget, I'm like, that's kind of high, that's kind of high for a type of film like this. Um, yeah, it, like usually these pieces need to be like, kind of toned down a little bit. Um, as far as budget-wise.

Casey G. Smith: Sure. Yeah, I, I was shocked because it, it had again, from the first initial image that I saw of, of Dwayne Johnson sitting, like it was like an in-ring shot of him sitting down with a prosthetic on his nose. I was like, oh, wow, he looks so different. And the, the, you know, the hairpiece that they were using. I was like, whoa. And then, when it started coming out and going like to the Venice Film Festival, I started, you know, getting standing ovations. It had like this buzz. Yeah, it had this buzz around it, but, uh, it did not come to fruition at the box office. And again, I'm, I'm sad to say I, I, I wanted to go see it in the theaters, but I, I didn't make my way out to see it. So, I'm, I'm just as, as guilty. But, uh, but yeah, that's, that's rough. That's a, that's a, that's a rough one. It's, it's, I believe the lowest opening weekend for any, uh, any film with, with Dwayne Johnson in the mix.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dang, that, yeah, that was crazy. You know, I would, I would, I wish, man, I wish I could have gone back and just like, all right, dive into why this happened. Like, did this drop around the same time like Cinners and stuff like that was kind of like, there was like, during this year, during 2025, in the box office, it was like switching between who was like kind of dominating the box office.

Critical Reception and Budget Considerations

Casey G. Smith: So, this one was released in October.

Reginald Titus Jr.: October.

Casey G. Smith: October 3rd is when it, is when it dropped.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay. And, uh, when we talk about, okay, so The Smashing Machine comes out in October, A24. I kind of anticipated it too, man, because I remember, we talked about it on the episode, you know, I was like, wow, did you see, like, it didn't even look like him. Which also makes me think is like, did that, was that also a contributing factor because he's not The Rock, you know? He's not The Rock. He's a different person in this film, and is that a contributing factor to it?

Casey G. Smith: That's a good question. Uh-huh.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Just by, just looking at the key art, like, you see this.

Casey G. Smith: Sure. No.

Reginald Titus Jr.: You know.

Casey G. Smith: And that, I don't know. Like, this is the image that I'm, I'm used to seeing for

Reginald Titus Jr.: For The Smashing Machine.

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, that image right there is the one I was more, more so used to seeing, but

Reginald Titus Jr.: I don't know which one's the official key art.

Casey G. Smith: I think this one is clearly that's the official key art. That is there.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Uh, this is a picture of like, uh, you know, Mark Kerr like, you know, kind of squaring up, uh, with Dwayne Johnson, but, you know, squaring up, got his hands into the frame. And you can kind of tell, you're like, the face looks familiar. You know, who is that? You know, it looks kind of like The Rock, you know, but he's got hair. Is it him?

Casey G. Smith: Yeah. I don't know, man. I, uh, I don't know, it would be fascinating to kind of take a deeper, deeper dive. Uh, when I talk about the reception of it, I'll be able to kind of, I think, touch on a little bit more of that. But just for context as far as release dates, Cinner's came out in February of last year. So, so they were quite a while apart.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay. They were done. Yeah. Um, what was I about to say? Um, this reminds me, you remember The Wrestler, the one with, uh, Mickey Rourke? Yeah. You remember that one?

Casey G. Smith: I do.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Uh, that's the energy that I, I didn't, no, I didn't see The Wrestler. I didn't go to the theater, I didn't see it, but I know about it because it's um, uh, it's the other guy, uh, the director, uh, Soderbergh. I believe that's Soderbergh. Steven Soderbergh that did that one, if I'm not mistaken. And this is the energy that I got from, from looking just at the key art and A24 and the style that approach, I was like, this is like The Wrestler. But The Wrestler, the budget was, you know, it was, he had to go down a little bit. And it's like, you kind of get, got to get down and dirty, you know, with some of these projects. I don't know what the budget was for The Wrestler.

Casey G. Smith: So, The Wrestler, which came out in 2008, in December of 2008, uh, had a $6 million budget. And, and worldwide grossed $45 million.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's what it, I feel like that's what this one needed, because when I see this, I think Wrestler when I see this. I was like, who's, I was like, how many people are going to go watch The Wrestler? If you look at the trailer,

Casey G. Smith: Oh, yeah. That's, that's, that's going to be niche in a, in a different kind of way.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And because of that, it's like, you can make your money, but you have to keep that budget low. And that's what I, I was surprised when I heard the budget for The Smashing Machine. I was like, it shouldn't be that high. Because that's just the energy I got. It's like independent, it's kind of like on the fringe.

Casey G. Smith: Well, it was also, I, I think, here's what I, what I'm, I'm going to assume, like, they, this director very much so was about like, being like on set. And so, they did shoot some in Japan, um, some other places. They, they, the home that they, that, that, that, uh, Mark Kerr and Donna are in, that's a whole set that was built.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right.

Casey G. Smith: I don't know. Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, you're saying, but you're saying these contributed to inflating the budget, is what you're meaning?

Casey G. Smith: Yes. Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay. Got it. Um,

Casey G. Smith: That's my assumption, those are the only two things I could think of.

Reginald Titus Jr.: definitely inflated the budget. You're going to build a whole set? I heard that on one of the interviews that, um, uh, Benny was on.

Casey G. Smith: Like, the whole, the whole house was

Reginald Titus Jr.: I was like, bro, that's too, that's, that's a million dollars. Like, no, you don't do that. Um, but, but when you have The Rock, you think you're going to go to the, you know, go out to the moon, but it, I, I feel like this is like one of those like darlings, like film festival darlings that, you know, has like a certain taste and doesn't really, isn't pop, you know, I got another movie that I want to compare to it. But dang, that sucks. Cause I really wanted it to do well. Um,

Casey G. Smith: Likewise.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, man. Um, but so, what was the sentiment at the time and kind of or how do people feel about it?

Casey G. Smith: So, uh, according to some, uh, Google AI feedback, it said, The Smashing Machine received generally positive critical reviews for its raw dramatic acting, particularly by Dwayne Johnson, but was a commercial, a major commercial flop. Uh, while it was praised at the Venice Film Festival for its artistic, documentary style, the film failed with audiences, earning a low $5.9 million opening. Critics praised the performances, but found the story directed by Benny Safti to be somewhat flat or repetitive, uh, notes one Reddit user.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dang.

News and Recent Watches

Casey G. Smith: Which I could, I could, I could see. I'll be honest, once we decided that we were going to watch this again, I was, I wasn't too excited to watch it again. I was like, cause I'd already watched it on, I, I watched it on HBO. And I was like, sorry about that.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, really?

Casey G. Smith: No, it's all good. I was like, okay, it's okay. I was like, but I wasn't like, oh, like when we said Cinner's, I'm like, okay, again, I've now Cinner's, I got more and more excited. And, and I will say, I've kind of appreciate The Smashing Machine a little bit more since I seen the behind the scenes stuff, but, but it, it doesn't excite me the way Cinner's does, because it's a, it's a, you know, The Smashing Machine is a sad story. Spoiler alert, it's a, it's a sad story. And it's

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, and it's sometimes you don't want to see that. Yeah.

Casey G. Smith: And it's not like a, it's not like a Rocky film, where he gets beat up, but, you know, aside from the major concussive brain damage he's obviously assuming in those fights, he's a fictional character and he technically wins.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. But, uh,

Casey G. Smith: Or at least draws, but

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dang. But yeah, it's just, yeah. Uh, but I'll say like, at the time, like some of the buzz that I remember was, I, and I can't remember what episode we were on when we, when we were talking about it, but just the buzz was about the look. It wasn't about the story. It wasn't about Mark Kerr. It was about, that don't look like Dwayne. You know what I mean? That was it. It was, it had nothing to do with the story. Now, people that are hardcore UFC fans, they were talking about, like, Daniel Cormier, he was talking about like, man, this guy, like, The Rock, he's legit. He's, he's a legit wrestler. I remember, and Daniel Cormier, everybody loves Daniel Cormier. Like, much respect. Everybody loves the guy. Huggable dude, but will kill you. You know what I mean? He's like, the opposite like Jonathan, uh, yeah, Jonathan Jones, you know, they're like, arch enemies. John Jones is like, I'll kill you. Like, when they're doing like, doing their face-offs, um, classic stuff. But yeah, uh, if Daniel gives you the praise, you are a legit UFC wrestler, because Daniel Cormier's, you know, in wrestling, but he's also a good striker. Uh, so I'm like, man, if he, if that dude is giving The Rock, the like, hey, you did your, you, you did it right. Then

Casey G. Smith: Yeah. To, to, to kind of, uh, piggyback off that, the director was very specific, and he, he talks about this a lot in the commentary and in the making of featurette on the, uh, the, the 4K Blu-ray about how he, I mean, he has all kinds of fighters within the film. You got guys like Bas Rutten, who was

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's my dude. And, we'll get into this in like, trivia and stuff like that, but, um, that's my guy. I, I saw his fights. And so I was like, he can, he can whoop butt right now. You know what I mean? Like, and he has like a weird kind of gene. So like, uh, in one of his, I don't know if you see the shot, when he took his shirt off, um, after he talks to Mark Kerr in there.

Casey G. Smith: Oh, real, real, yeah, real briefly. Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Still cut up.

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, that's the direction he goes, yeah, he's, he could still, you know, fight today. Even though he's supposed to like, be himself from 15, almost 20 years ago.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. But he still can kick butt. So, he has like a, like some like different with his genetics, where he like still kicks off testosterone, like a younger person. So, that's why he's still like jacked. You know, you get like these people that are like superheroes, you know, like some people can memorize things from like, when they were like two years old, and they still have a memory of it, and things like that.

Casey G. Smith: Eidetic memory. Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: You know, the photographic memory or whatever, but like, in total recall, but like, this guy has this thing that

Casey G. Smith: His genes have total recall. We live in a, you use mold engage.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes. Yeah, man. He'll, but he'll kick butt today. So, speaking of when, when we talked about like the fanfare that The Smashing Machine had coming out of, of Venice, uh, and the, the kind of praise and hype for the look of the film, when we talked about potential awards. So it, it has been nominated for an Academy Award for best achievement in makeup and hairstyling. Uh, as of this recording, the Academy Awards have not taken place yet, but, uh, shortly after this, this episode comes out, the Academy Awards will happen, and we'll see, we'll see how it does. I wish, um, Dwayne got nominated. DJ, whatever, you know, just because, uh, yeah, we'll talk about it, but I wish he would have got nominated, because it's like one of those things like, we'll talk about it. Oh, man. Anyhow, any, any other sentiment, uh, at the time?

Casey G. Smith: That's pretty much it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: All right. Well, before we talk further about The Smashing Machine, let's talk about TV news and movies we watched.

Casey G. Smith: So in the news, according to Variety, Warner Brothers Discovery declares new Paramount bid a superior proposal. Netflix at the, at, well, Netflix had four business days to, to match the new bid by Paramount for the purchase of Warner Brothers Discovery. Of course, previously Netflix had made a pretty nicely sized proposal to Warner Brothers for their purchase, and Warner Brothers had actually signed an initial agreement. So, over the course of the week and, and, and the weekend, Netflix actually bowed out, which leads to another, um, another headline that says, uh, this is by the, via The Guardian, that says, Netflix quits Warner Brothers takeover battle, and, um, yeah. So, so now Paramount is, is poised to, if, uh, you know, all regulatory approvals happen, they're poised to purchase Warner Brothers Discovery. But, the third article, or headline that then kind of capsulates some of this, is that, Paramount pays Netflix $2.8 billion termination fee over the Warner Brother exit deal. So, within the, I'd buy that for a dollar. Or $2.8 billion.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's billion, right?

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, billion with a B.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, my God, that's a good deal.

Casey G. Smith: So, within, within the clause that when, when HBO initially signed their agreement with Netflix, if there was a termination, Warner Brothers Discovery would pay Netflix $2.8 billion. Of course, Paramount went and said, went ahead and said, we got you covered, we'll take care of that. There you go. So, Netflix comes out $2.8 billion richer.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's crazy. Um, uh, your guy, uh, Campia, um, I just had them like, kind of playing in the background, you know, like kind of talking about all this stuff, cause even me and you, you know, we were texting back and forth about the whole situation with Netflix and all that stuff, just, it's kind of just fun to talk about. Um, but, um, they were kind of speculating that it's a possibility that they're going to like, drop HBO and like, kind of absorb it into Paramount.

Casey G. Smith: That would be, I would be very sad. I would be very sad about that.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Where Netflix strategy was, it's, it's its own thing that generates income, and we're going to leave it alone, and everybody and all the executives, do your thing, and et cetera. But this is, I don't know if this is true or not, but they're saying that it's going to get all kind of swallowed up into Paramount.

Casey G. Smith: Personally, I hope this doesn't go through. I'm, I'm at a point now where I was okay with, with the Netflix aspect of things, cause I think, I think Netflix was generally, genuinely trying to get into the theaters, like more of their releases into theaters and they would, and they would leave HBO alone. And this is, this is personal bias because I literally grew up with HBO.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Same. I'm, I'm right there with you, like, leave it alone. It's one of the few streaming platforms that even if there's like nothing new, you, it's okay paying for it because it's curated and you're like, kind of like in safe hands, you know, with their TV shows.

Casey G. Smith: They're, they're the, they, they are the best. They're like taste. They, they give you taste. You, you can't buy that. Some of these places, some other places like, I ain't going to say who, but some places are like dumping grounds, right? And you can never find the films. When you, man, when I just, just like, you think of some of the, the amazing shows that HBO has produced over the past 40 plus years. Whether you talk about, again, when I was a kid watching, you know, shows like Dream On, which is not, you know, Dream On, and I, I shouldn't be watching, but Dream On, Tales from the Crypt, we

Reginald Titus Jr.: Well, dude, Tales from the Crypt isn't on HBO.

Casey G. Smith: I know, I know, it's a shame. But that's where it started, but

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, my God, I, because we, the only reason cause we were recently trying to look for, I was trying to get my kids. I was like, you don't know who Tales from the Crypt. I was like, how did I miss this? Let's go find it. It's HBO. It should be on there. No, it's not. Because the comic book didn't, they didn't do the, the thing that they were supposed to do.

Casey G. Smith: Yeah. Another one, uh, Def Comedy Jam. Which is also not on HBO.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Hello, mother, But it is on Amazon.

Casey G. Smith: It's also, it's on no Prime. I, I, I watched an episode. I was like, I felt like, man, this is, man, this 90s comedy. I felt

Reginald Titus Jr.: It's bad. It's, you just listened to a

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, from this, it's, it's, it's, yeah, but it's that one, I forget her name, but she was like, how you doing? How your mama doing?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, who is that?

Casey G. Smith: I forget her name, but she was, oh, man.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Man, you know, LT and Ice-T were both sitting up in the balcony.

Casey G. Smith: Anyway, I'm not going to too much. But man, HBO's content, right? We go from Def Jam to Sex and the City, The Sopranos, The Wire, then we get, uh, we get

Reginald Titus Jr.: Uh, Six Feet Under, Six Feet.

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, Six Feet, Six Feet Under. You have Oz. You have, uh, you have, what am I trying to say? I've lost my train of thought. You have just so many shows. Enlightened. You have True Blood. You have, uh, Entourage. The list goes on, right? The list goes on. You got Game of Thrones.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's like, that's like what they're known for is creating TV series since the beginning. Some of the, some of the best. And that was, and they were, they were the channel that were giving you the uncut, the uncensored version of movies that when, when they would get poured over to regular cable, you know, you know, they, they, they, they things would get censored, but HBO gave you the, gave you the raw. And they had the comedy specials too.

Casey G. Smith: Oh, man. Dave Chappelle, him softly. Classic. That's true. So, I, I hope that this deal does not go through. And I'm not

Reginald Titus Jr.: For those reasons, right? Don't mess with the other properties like that. Here's the thing. Warner Brothers, from a film standpoint, they're also cranking out good, I mean, original films. Cinners is under Warner Brothers. And even, uh, One Battle After Another also is under Warner Brothers. And there's a third film I'm, I'm forgetting, but that's all under them. Like, so why, why do you all need to, to be sold?

Casey G. Smith: More. More. Like, what's, what's, what's going on? Yeah, what's, what's going on where you feel you need to be sold? Because you've, you've gone through multiple hands over the past decade. You went, you AT&T bought you, and then Discovery bought you. It's like, like, just, like, do what you do. And, I don't know. Maybe they have too much debt. I don't know what the situation is, but I, I have a feeling that if Paramount, this purchase goes through, there's going to be a lot of layoffs as well.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes, they're going to cut, there was a number, Campia and them were talking about. There's an actual number. It's in the billions, that this getting cut regardless. So like, in the billions.

Casey G. Smith: I, I know, I know that they're trying to offload a certain amount of debt. And even I, I read an article a while back where they, how they were restructuring and putting X amount of stuff over here to kind of separate. Anyway, this part's going a little too long, but, but that's where things are at right now. And also in the news, uh, Scream had a fantastic debut. Scream 7 had a fantastic debut. Uh, I want to say over over like 500 some

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's cool.

Casey G. Smith: Uh, I've been kind of hearing on online, like, you know, there's political things involved, you know, with it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, yeah.

Casey G. Smith: But, like, the fans like it, but then there are, like, I guess there's some like things going on with like one, the actor that, uh, got dismissed.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Melissa Barrera, who spoke out on behalf of Palestine.

Casey G. Smith: She's Palestinian. I don't think she is, but she, she spoke out on behalf of them. Um, and just some of the, the, the, the war-related things that were happening. And so, they're, there are people there because she was then like, let go from the franchise because of her comments. And, and she's not in this film, but neither is, uh, the girl who's playing her, her sister, Jennifer Ortega. That they're not, they're not even in this, this, this film.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Interesting.

Casey G. Smith: And so, yeah, but people are, yeah, they were protesting the film. boycotting it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That makes sense. Um, it's kind of weird. It's, um, I think, it's one of those things that, um, hmm, what can I say about this? Kind of, I don't want to say stay in your lane, but kind of stay in your lane with what you're doing because we've, we've seen when the actors start talking about things that are kind of out of their lane, that it affects the properties that they're on. Um, it happened with, uh, what's that guy from, uh, Fantastic Four? Uh, what's his name? Um, Pedro Pascal. Yeah, him. The, the most probably infamous cases, Rachel Zegler. Um, you know, yeah, that one's probably like the most infamous one. Like, they kind of, they ran her off the internet.

Casey G. Smith: Yeah, it, it gets, it gets tough. But nonetheless, Scream 7 is doing well at the box office. That's cool. A strong opening. Rock and roll. Stay away from those politics, guys. Just keep dancing and tapping.

What We've Been Watching

Reginald Titus Jr.: Um, all right, man, what have you been watching?

Casey G. Smith: Okay, we're going to drop two because we typically talk more about the things we've been watching on our new spinoff series, uh, simply called What We've Been Watching. So you can find more episodes of that in the same place you can find episodes of Filmmaker Commentary, the usual places. But I'll, I'll mention two things I've been watching, and can I throw in a trailer as well?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes, indeed.

Casey G. Smith: All right. So one of the trailers that I saw, and this is actually a correction I need to make from last week. Excuse me, of last episode. I had mentioned two things that I, I got wrong. One, I called the, the show, uh, Nights of the Seven Kingdoms, when it's simply called A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, that's the Game of Thrones spinoff.

Casey G. Smith: Game of Thrones spinoff, which had, just had its finale. And we were talking, and I said, I think I think that House of Dragons is done. Well, no, I was wrong, because one of the trailers that I saw recently was for the third season of House of Dragon. So that is going to be coming back also this year as well. So they have, we have two Game of Thrones spinoff series that are ongoing.

Reginald Titus Jr.: HBO strikes again.

Casey G. Smith: Haha. And as far as, oh, go ahead.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay, I'm going to switch off with you. Um, kind of, have you been keeping up with like the Epstein stuff at all? Or catching hints of it or anything like that?

Casey G. Smith: Yes, it's, it's, it's everywhere. It's almost inescape. It's a mess.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Um, so in that, I don't, people were talking about this, so, apparently, um, you know, the Department of Justice, they, you know, revealed all the stuff, and they got people are, it's taking them, it's going to probably take them years to go through all this crap, that's how much stuff it is. Have you ever, I clicked on it, it's like all these Google files of just, just documents, and documents, documents. It's going to take your lifetime to go through it. Uh, but, they were saying that they were hunting black people. Like, they were literally hunting them like animals. Like, on some of these islands, like letting them run out and do their thing and they like shooting them down like animals.

Casey G. Smith: Wow.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, that came out in some of the Epstein, and so, and like, that's so like, over the last couple weeks, people have been getting like, like, pissed about this and like, you know, kind of talking about.

Casey G. Smith: I, I had not heard that.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, really? Yeah, yeah. So, over the last week, and I knew about it because my, my wife, she had talked about it because she, she's been keeping up with this stuff. And, uh, and I didn't, you know, I started looking at those documents, I was like, ain't no way I'm going to be able to read all this stuff. I don't have the time. Um, but yeah, but people are going through these documents. But it led me, I was like, you know what that reminds me of? It reminds me of a movie that I watched, 1994, Ice-T, Surviving the Game. Do you remember that?

Casey G. Smith: Maybe. I, I've seen, I've seen films where people are being hunted. Steve, Steve Austin, Stone Cold Steve Austin was in a film years ago, where it was about that. People get dropped somewhere and they, they are being hunted, like, like animals.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, this is specifically black dudes, right? Um, he's, Ice-T, he, he, he wants to end his life. He's a homeless guy, you know, but I think he's got like a background of military or something like that. But he wants to end his life. He's about to jump in front of a truck, uh, 18-wheeler. And then right before he, he does it, remember the, what's the brother that played The Rock, uh, Rock, uh, the TV show Rock?

Casey G. Smith: Charles S. Dutton.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Out of nowhere, jumps, saves Ice-T's life, right? He's like, man, what are you doing? You know, you know, you get it together. Hey, man, you need a job, and he gives him a card. Gives him a card and, you know, he goes to this location, and, um, and in the woods or whatever, and it's like, these, um, uh, Busey, characters like Busey, and all them.

Casey G. Smith: Oh, Gary Busey.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes. Oh, man. You know, he always plays it. He's terrible. He's like a perfect villain. And so all these guys, and they're feeding Ice-T and doing all this stuff. And someone like, pulls like a pig head and look at him, and he's looking around, and he see all these heads on the wall. And he's being hunted. He said, hey, you got 15 minutes to go. They give him like a 4x4, he like takes off, and then like the whole movie is about hunting this character. I said, this reminds me of that. And, um, it's crazy how like some things are like kind of shown in the movies in a way, and then it comes out in reality. I was like, man, this is, this is wild. It's real wild.

Casey G. Smith: I'm ask you about something else. Once we get offline, I'll ask you about something else that I saw.

Reginald Titus Jr.: I can dig it. All right.

Casey G. Smith: Um, so you've been watching that via, uh,

Reginald Titus Jr.: No, I just watched the trailer, because I, I was, uh, this is one of the trailers I watched, because I just rewatched the trailer. And, uh, because it, that memory, like, listening to what they're saying, I was like, if this is true, this reminds me of this movie in the 90s. And then I, I showed it to my wife and she's like, what the heck? I said, yeah, I was like, this has already been talked about before. Man. Yeah. Surviving the Game. I was like, man, this, and it's like, it's available on Blu-ray and DVD and all that stuff. I was like, man, this might be cool to go back and watch.

Casey G. Smith: Okay. So, something that I, I did watch that was new, was actually Scream 7. Went to the theaters with, with two of my buddies. Um, and yeah, we sat down, we watched Scream 7, the, the, the return of Sydney. Yes, Sydney. She was in the mix with her now with her daughter as well. And

Reginald Titus Jr.: Strong women.

Casey G. Smith: Exactly. And she's, you know, she's, she's, you know, married, got, got, got, got her husband, her bae. And again, I don't want to give too much away, but it was, it was, it was, it was solid. And there were, there were, there were, there were, there are two characters, I, I think they're actually on the movie poster, but they've been in the past several Scream. It's the twins. Oh, okay. They back. They keep, they keep like showing, showing up. That's cool. And, uh, they, they, they have good, those two have good chemistry together as on-screen siblings. And, uh, yeah, but they, you know, again, Scream always has to play with the tropes and, and keeps you guessing. And I, I, I never, I never guess right who the

Reginald Titus Jr.: The killer? Did it like, uh, the person that does the voices, they get angry? They say, you know, when they do the, uh,

Casey G. Smith: Yeah. There's always a little bit of frustration that comes from. And they always, you know, the opening is, you know, what, what, what you will expect, you know, somebody somewhere and, and, you know, it, it always kicks off the same way. And, and it's always super meta because within the Scream universe, you have the Stab film franchise. That's right. That, that, uh, so yeah, it's very interesting what they, what they do, what they use, what kind of technologies incorporated. But yes, Scream 7 in theaters now.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Scream, uh, this is my next trailer, and this is kind of pretty much it. Um, the reason I had watched this trailer, I talked about this movie before, but I watched this trailer because the movie we're covering, The Smashing Machine, reminds me of this film. Um, remember Magazine Dreams, Jonathan Majors? Yes. Rewind, I had to show my wife again, because I'm already like trying to expose, you know, different trailers. I said, man, this, I said, this film reminds me of, uh, what Magazine Dreams should have been. Um, you know, this, uh, bodybuilder?

Casey G. Smith: Bodybuilder.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, bodybuilder. Well, I, I just, yeah, it's Jonathan Majors, he's a bodybuilder. I don't know what's going on with my, didn't watch the actual film. But I was like, let me go watch this trailer again because, um, at that time, I, uh, uh, Jonathan Majors was going through, you know, things publicly with his ex-girlfriend and stuff like that, and kind of like, jacked his career up for a couple of years, maybe a few years. And, uh, this movie, cause it won, I think the audience award at Sundance, uh, Magazine Dreams. And was supposed to be like, one of those character films that, you know, that's low budget, but it should catapult you as an actor. Uh, but because of all the drama that was going on at the time, they just kind of buried it.

Casey G. Smith: It was, it was supposed to be distributed by Disney.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dang. Yeah, and they, they dropped it as well. This would have, this would have put Jonathan Majors on the map. He was, he was already on the map. Like Oscar, like, you know, when I see, when I think about The Smashing Machine, I was like, this should at least be nominated. He's at least be nominated.

Casey G. Smith: I, yeah, I agree. This is the again, we're going to get into it. This is Dwayne Johnson's best performance.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. And so, that's what this one reminded me. I was like, dang, what could have been, right? In another timeline, they both won. Um, but, but yeah, that's all. I just kind of, kind of watched a couple of trailers. Uh, didn't have that much time this week, but that's what I watched.

Casey G. Smith: Okay. So my, my other film that I watched, and again, I, I watched a lot, but again, you can find out more on what we've been watching. That's right. But the other one I've watched is a film I've never seen before, but I remember seeing the trailers for it when I was a kid. Oh. It's called Colors.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh, man, The Cops. Colors. Colors. Colors. Colors. What, you want to be upset by the police? Watch that.

Casey G. Smith: Well, so, had you seen it before?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Long time ago. Like, I all I remember, was it, who, how was he escaping? It was a brother that was like, I don't know if he was driving on a motorcycle or a car, but he was wide open. Is it the right film?

Casey G. Smith: There is a, there is a, there are a couple of chase scenes in, in the film. But here's, here's the interesting about Colors. Number one, it's directed by Dennis Hopper. Well, I was like, oh, wow, that's fascinating. And it's obviously dealing with, with gangs in LA.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And my brother from South Central was in there, right?

Casey G. Smith: Yes, shoot, the whole, the, the cast is like a, a, a now like a who's who of various actors. So, a couple of examples, like the main two characters, the main two cops in the film, Robert Duval. Sean Penn. That's right. Yeah. And, and Sean Penn is the, is the young, like, the young cop. Duval is the, is the older cop who's on the, on the verge of, of getting his pension, like a year out from getting his pension.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Lord.

Casey G. Smith: Uh, you have, uh, one, uh, Maria Conchita Alonso, who is all up in the mix in the 80s. She's, she's the counterpart to Arnold in The Running Man.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dang, that's right. She's in a lot of stuff in the 80s. She's doing her thing. Um, you have Don Cheadle. That's right. Playing the main, uh, crypt called Rocket. There are a few lines in still. Okay, I've only seen clips then. I haven't seen the whole thing. I've only seen clips, cause I would have known. I would have

Casey G. Smith: It's, again, if you just watch the trailer, you could draw a conclusion of, of like, kind of thinking you know what it's about, but it's, it, I, I don't know how to say guaranteed, but it was much better than I thought it would be. And, and it wasn't, it wasn't as, So, I, I'll, I'll put it this way. So Robert Duval, so, you have, you have a, uh, you have obviously Los Angeles Police Department, but you have a specific sector of the police department that's, that's working, uh, working to try and like bust the, like, trying to like, work with the gangs or bust the gangs. And there's violence all around. Again, like, you see, literally, like, in one of the earlier scenes, like Don Cheadle and his crew, uh, along with Damon Wayans. Oh, Damon Wayans. Oh, that reminds me of something I watched. Damon, Damon Wayans is, is playing one of the gangsters. Leon is in the mix as well. He's one of the crips also. You know, it's, it's crazy. Like, wait, that's, that's, that's, it's so many. But they literally mowed down, uh, uh, this one young blood. Like, he's literally a blood. Gets mowed down on his front lawn. And kind of carries from there. But as the, as the film progresses, you see that Robert Duval's character is trying to, trying to teach Sean Penn's character the, the, the ropes. But Sean Penn's character is far more aggressive. Full of piss. And he's fast too. Like, he, he, he, like, you know, run people down and he's roughing them up. And Duval's like, hey, that's enough, that's enough. He's trying to get him constantly to calm down. And Duval tries to, he tries to work with people. He tries to like, give them a break. They can catch, you know, catch some, you know, young kids with, with drugs or whatever. They can come, hey, you know, you want to hang around these guys? You want to be like these guys? You know, you need to, you know, like, do better or whatever. Like, he tries to, he's not just out to try to bust them, he's trying to help them. Like, get them, like, get to a better place. And so, you, you see more of, of this kind of advocacy taking place. And it's this juxtaposition between Duval's character and Sean Penn's character. Which, I'll, I'll say this, after also having seen One Battle After Another and the character that Sean Penn plays in that, it almost made me think, oh, man, he almost, it almost feels a little bit like a continuation. Early on, it almost feels like, oh, man, this guy could almost be a continuation. When you see the film. Okay. You'd have to kind of see both. But see both, you're like, oh, man. But they got different names. I, I didn't look the name up just to be sure. Just to be sure. Just to be sure. But, uh, yeah, , though, man, I was, uh, I was, I was impressed with the film. It, it they're dealing with some heavy stuff, but it's, again, in my opinion, it's, it's not like just, oh, the cops out here beating up gang members and harassing them. No, but these gang members are, they're, they're, they're, they're, they're terrorizing. And even, and even the people in the neighborhood, they're, they're coming to like, these, uh, police, um, like, I don't know, not rallies, but they're coming to like these town hall community meetings, saying, okay, what are y'all going to do about these gangs? Because we're not safe in our own neighborhoods. And it's, and some of the, the brothers in the meeting are like, well, what the hell do you think we've been doing? Like, and they said, we came from Nam. Like, like, that, that, that, that backdrop of the Vietnam is getting so prevalent in a lot of 80s films. But anyway, Colors on Amazon Prime. Colors. I remember a tidbit, like, behind the scenes, when, uh, the brother that plays, uh, in South Central in the character, and Sean Penn, I think, knees him in the groin or something like that. I think the director was like, hey, put a cup on. Um, and this is the actor talking about this. Uh, they were like, fighting, and they were like, hitting for real and stuff like that. And then he was like, yeah, put on a cup. But he said, I ain't going to try to put it. He said, trust me, put on a cup. And then gets smashed in the, in the stuffings. And like, dude was like, he's pissed, you know, the actor rightfully so, you know, like, you're not letting them know that you're going to get hit and stuff like that. And then he tells you that, cause if he didn't tell him that, he would have hit, you know, got him in the balls, you know, and they would have, that would have made the film. You know what I mean? Like a lot of those real hits made the film.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. Uh, that's what we were getting a lot of that from. But I remember seeing the bad, was it Bad Boy or bad?

Director's Vision and Film Style

Casey G. Smith: Um, but so, yeah, so that's the, that's like the first scene, you know, they're coming out of those pyramids like, what is this? And then, um, while, while this is happening, we hear the voiceover of Mark Kerr and with the voice, you know, I like fighting and like, I like to hear the crowd roaring and, you know, he's explaining like his fighting style, I was like, okay. And then like, no more fights, you know, kind of goes into this other thing like, okay, I'll come back tomorrow and watch it. But like the tone is set like very early on. It's going to be highly stylized and this is a period piece. Oh, yeah. definitely set, set staunchly in the 90s, the styles, the music. We are in it. And like, kind of speaking of style, you you mentioned the 16 mm film. You definitely feel it. Like you see it. I was like, this looks dated. They did a good job with that. Uh, I, I think Spring Breakers, I don't know if it was Super 16, did they shot when we covered Spring Breakers, but it seemed like it popped more, but I love Super 16. I don't know if this was Super 16 or just regular 16 mm. Um, I like Super 16 better. Uh, 16 mm, definitely feels dated. Sure. Um, but, but so and also they did a lot of handheld. So like, early on, like, oh, they're doing handheld. Then you, and then in the middle of a, uh, a shot, you see the zoom go in and then zoom go. I was like, I don't know if I like, like, it took me a while to kind of get used to it. Cause, cause like that was like a popular, especially in the 90s with action. It was like, okay, everybody's doing handheld, you know, early 2000s, everybody was doing handheld. So that's what remind me of like with the handheld. So it took me about 30 minutes to get used to it. And I was like, I was like, okay, I'm here. I'm with these people now. Yes, sir. You're in his world. We are, man. And you feel the blows. And when he gets those knees to the head, um, seeing how he, first, he goes to the, um, to the room to kind of gather some, he just starts crying, you know, he starts crying, oh, my God. And it's a pretty like long tracking shot. We follow him back there. Man. It's so lonely. It's so lonely. Into the elevator. It's so lonely. Takes your stop, guys, we got food. Oh, can't go in there. Nope. Can't go up. We go up some more. Oh, man. Go into the room. So lonely. And, uh, sit down. Yep. Starts crying. Oh, man. Oh, no. And then like, right before that, uh, one of the journalists was like, so if you do fight, if you do fight, if you do lose, you know. I was like, dang, he's like, kind of putting some doubt into his brain a little bit. He's like, but what if you do, you know? Uh, how would you respond? I mean, I'm not a never lost before. Yeah. For real. Um, I don't have any more tips. You got any more tips?

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's all I got, my friend.

Casey G. Smith: I would just add a couple of things. Um, uh, Mark Kerr. Um, I was started listening to an interview with Mark Kerr with Joe Rogan and they were talk, he was talking about his son. And his son was like, when, um, he watched, uh, Dwayne play him. He was like, dude, that's you, dad. That's like your doppelganger. Even though even his walk is different. Yeah, yeah. Cause The Rock has like a very specific walk. You know, it's like, that big old sucker like that. He's like, I'm, it's a walk like I'm the man. It's almost like Denzel Washington, right? It's just like, but the swoll version. It's just like, hey, man, ain't nobody messing with me. You know. He has a couple of different walks. Pervious to bullets. Man. There, there's a way that he walks when he's doing The Rock. Yeah. There's a way that he walks when he's Dwayne Johnson like movie, movie star. Yeah. But as Mark Kerr, he has a, yeah, he has a different, the way he carries his weight, even like where his chest and his butt are at. Like, when he walks, it was, it was, it was just different. Like, the, the steps are kind of like smaller. Yeah. Very fast. I'm like, he is, he building, like, they say, you build them from the, the ground up, right? How do they stand? Yeah, he's, he's doing it all. Man. Um, so it's been great to see, um, just, you know, the resurgence in a way of Mark Kerr, you know, to like, the zeitgeist of the, of what's going on currently with fighting. Uh, it's cool to see that because these people get lost behind because like, I was like, I have memories of this person. I just didn't know the person's name. I remember seeing his fights. Absolutely. Again, seeing Bas Rutten, I'm like, yo, this guy was in my Japanese wrestling game. I, I, I remember this guy knocking people out. Also another guy that just recently got interviewed. It was like, oh, this is like all back to back stuff because they were getting ready for, you know, The Smashing Machine. And, uh, there's so much, I wish I was able to do more of a deep dive on the film just because there's so many interviews. It's almost like they were expecting it to be like, you know, hey, we're about to get nominated. We about this is it. Because they put the work in. They put the work in. They did. They did. Again, I, I, I wish this had done better at the box office, and I wish I had contributed to, uh, to that. Alas, I did not. Yeah. But, nonetheless, it is, it is what it is. But yeah, if you are interested in checking out The Smashing Machine, again, it is currently streaming on HBO. Yes. Catch it while you can. That's right. For our next episode, we will be diving into the film Bogonia with one Jesse Plemons and Emma Stone. Yet another film, uh, directed by I'm going to get this gentleman's name right. He's done a number of films with him. Bogonia. The key art's very interesting, uh, to look at. I'm like, what is this, you know, I was getting the Oscar buzz. I'm like, what is this about? Sign me up, though. Have you seen any of the trailers for it? I did. You did? Yeah. I, I saw some. I'm like, oh, man, this is. But man, I tell you what, Jesse Plemons, he's, he's kind of low-key one of my favorite actors. Dang, okay. Yeah, cause he just, he plays so many variations in roles and he's just, he's his choices are interesting to me. But, uh, Yorgos Lanthimos. Oh, okay. I believe he's Greek. So, I'm so glad he said put some respect on my name. Yes, Yorgos. Um, but in the meantime, you can catch us where? Facebook.com/filmmakercommentary. We're on iTunes, SoundCloud, and Spotify where you can like and subscribe. You can also find us at Filmmaker.com. where you can read some great articles by one. Filmmaker Commentary. You take Filmmaker account? My bad. I forgot to delete that word. I will say it again. Gladiator. You can catch the Filmmaker Commentary.com. We're also on YouTube/filmmaker and on the gram at Filmmaker Commentary. Yeah. And, uh, where we try to post on Facebook as well. But you, yeah, on Facebook also. So, on all the, the main, well, on most of the main feeds, we're not really doing much on X or on, uh, Nah. on, on the, the tick of the tocks. Nah. Um, but, until next time, peace. Respect. And, uh, yeah, thanks for tuning in. And until next time, peace.

About Filmmaker Commentary

Reginald Titus Jr.

Apple Spotify YouTube Subscribe Free
Continue Listening

FMC 254 : Scream 7 Directed by Kevin Williamson

November 13, 2026

FMC 253 : It Follows Directed by David Robert Mitchell

November 7, 2026

FMC 252 : Talk to Me Directed by Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou

October 25, 2026

Leave a Response Cancel reply

Never Miss an Episode

New episodes every week — free.

Listen on Spotify Apple Podcasts

Recent Episodes

  • FMC 254 : Scream 7 Directed by Kevin Williamson
  • FMC 253 : It Follows Directed by David Robert Mitchell
  • FMC 252 : Talk to Me Directed by Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou
  • FMC 251 : Weapons Directed by Zachary Michael Cregger

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • November 2025
  • September 2025
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • March 2021
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017

Categories

  • Film
  • Podcast
  • TV
© 2026 Filmmaker Commentary. All rights reserved.
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service