November 18, 2026
F
Filmmaker Commentary
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Film
  • TV
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Film
  • TV
Podcast

FMC 023: Filmmaker David Fincher’s Fight Club

June 26, 2018
Listen on Apple Spotify YouTube
Listen to this episode
Your browser does not support the audio element.
Also on Apple Spotify YouTube

Filmmaker Commentary’s latest episode offers a deep dive into David Fincher’s iconic Fight Club, exploring the film’s intricate themes and Fincher’s notoriously meticulous filmmaking process. Hosts Reginald Titus Jr. and Casey G. Smith revisit the 1999 classic through its director’s commentary, uncovering new insights for aspiring filmmakers and dedicated cinephiles alike.

What We Cover

  • How Fight Club’s initial box office performance contrasted with its cultural legacy and later appreciation.
  • The unique experience of rewatching the film years later, especially for those encountering its famous twist for the first time.
  • David Fincher’s distinctive, informal commentary style and his focus on overcoming production challenges.
  • The clever, hidden details and special features baked into the physical media releases of *Fight Club*, reflecting Fincher’s attention to every aspect of the viewer’s experience.
  • A discussion of the film’s enduring themes, including anti-consumerism, masculinity, and identity, and their continued relevance.
  • Insights into Fincher’s directorial preferences, from his use of practical blood to his demanding approach with actors.

Key Moments

  • 01:50 — Casey G. Smith shares his initial viewing experience, revealing his surprise at the film’s ending and how a rewatch shifts perspective.
  • 03:30 — Discussion on the groundbreaking visual effects, including the opening brain synapse sequence, and their surprising longevity.
  • 05:40 — Exploration of *Fight Club*’s thematic layers, including consumerism, freedom, and sadomasochism, and how these elements surprised one host’s spouse on a rewatch.
  • 15:35 — The hosts detail Fincher’s informal commentary style and how he packs valuable insights into every minute, even without a formal introduction or outro.
  • 21:30 — A humorous dive into the film’s original, legally controversial joke, the changes made due to studio concerns, and how the new line unexpectedly garnered more laughs.
  • 26:30 — The hosts discuss Fincher’s preference for practical blood over digital, using the infamous “Lou’s Tavern” scene as a prime example of its visceral impact.

Gear & Films Mentioned

  • DVD / Blu-ray discs
  • The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
  • Zodiac
  • Gone Girl
  • Panic Room
  • Oceans Eleven
  • The Rocky Horror Picture Show
  • Aeon Flux
  • Memento
  • The Prestige
  • House of Cards
  • Orphan Black

Listener Questions

  • How did *Fight Club* perform financially upon its initial release, and how did that impact its perception?
  • What makes David Fincher’s director commentaries unique, and how can filmmakers benefit from listening to them?
  • How do Fincher’s special features and packaging design extend the storytelling experience beyond the film itself?

Full Transcript

Read the full transcript

Full Episode Transcript

This episode of Filmmaker Commentary David Fincher's "Fight Club," exploring its controversial themes, production challenges, visual effects, and director commentary, alongside personal re-watch experiences and industry insights.

Opening Discussion & Initial Impressions of Fight Club

Reginald Titus Jr.: Filmmaker Commentary, episode 23. Welcome to Filmmaker Commentary, where we give you insights from our favorite filmmaker commentaries. These commentaries can be heard on your DVD and Blu-rays of your favorite movies. We'll show you how you can use these commentaries and apply them to improve your video production and filmmaking techniques. All of this here on Filmmaker Commentary. I'm your host, Reginald Titus Jr.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Welcome to another episode of Filmmaker Commentary. I'm Reginald Titus Jr. I'm here with Casey G. Smith. Welcome back, sir.

Casey G. Smith.: Good to be back, sir.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Today we're talking about Fight Club, an American classic. The budget for this film was what? $63 million. At the box office, domestically, $37 million. And foreign made $63.8 million. Would we consider this a win?

Casey G. Smith.: I'd say definitely. I mean, , I mean, 101 million. I don't know what the P&A would have been, maybe on top of that 63 mil.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Like, when you don't win your budget back domestically, I'm like, I wonder from a studio standpoint, do they, what do they consider that?

Casey G. Smith.: Well, I mean, back then, they probably, maybe not so much. Because, you know, in '99, worldwide box office didn't have any, anywhere near the sway that it has now. Now, it's very much so about the worldwide box office. I think they would have felt they probably like, maybe broke even. And you know that that that budget I probably so high, mainly because probably the the the visual effects in the film.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Of course. That freaking Fincher always burns through the budget and then has to reshoot.

Casey G. Smith.: But man, it's a it's a hell of a film.

Reginald Titus Jr.: It is, one of the best. One of my top top 20 films for sure. How did you view it this time around? And when was your first time seeing it, and how did you view it this time?

Casey G. Smith.: So first time I saw Fight Club was when you let me you let me borrow it. Uh so anywhere between probably 2013, 2014, somewhere around there. And I watched it, I knew nothing about it. I had seen images of, you know, Brad Pitt in his jacket and Edward Norton, I'd seen the bar of soap, and I was like, what? What is this? I I didn't I didn't know. I thought it was just about dudes fighting. And I'm like, oh, I'm like, I like, you know, seeing, you know, fighting and violence. I'm okay with that, but I was just like, ah, I don't know. It just it didn't it didn't draw me. And I but I didn't know anything about it. So, when I watched it the first time, obviously, the twist at the end, I was like, what? And that that took me for a loop. So this go around, I I hadn't watched it since then. So it's been about four or five years.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right.

Casey G. Smith.: And so watching it again this time, I was watching Edward Norton's character specifically to see how other characters interacted with him. Uh specifically when you watch him interact with Helena Bonham Carter's character, Marla, those interactions take a totally different feeling to them. When she's talking to him and asking him questions and her reactions to him. The first time I was like, what's wrong with her? Now I'm like, oh, this dude's tripping. Because she literally just spent, you know, the night and they've been going at it all night long. And now he acts like he doesn't even know her. And to her, he's like he's coming across as a jerk, but no, he literally doesn't remember. We talking about just like split personality and and

Reginald Titus Jr.: Crazy.

Casey G. Smith.: And when you begin to see that, just the progression of it, it really those elements are were were definitely enjoyable this time around. Even an appreciation for the effects. Uh again, I think some of them still hold up pretty decent. Uh even even, you know, in 2018, this is back in '99. So, uh and it's some pretty innovative things, especially even that opening shot coming out of the the the fear synapses in the brain going off and that. Still pretty freaking awesome. Like, to come all the way out like that. It is long. Again, I got nothing against long films. Don't get me wrong. It is long. I did feel that a little bit. The second go around, it may just been a long day. Which happens sometimes. So, yeah, I I enjoyed seeing it again the second time and I definitely watched it with with different eyes. How about you?

Revisiting Themes and Director's Vision

Reginald Titus Jr.: First time I watched it when it came out. Didn't go to the theaters, but when it came out on disc, like, it just spoke to my soul for whatever reason. Me, my sister, a couple of my friends, we would just watch this thing over and over again. Like, we would know the lines, like, Tyler Durden, the way he would laugh, Brad Pitt. That sick crazy laugh. It's just hilarious. We would try to do that laugh. Um so like, it's embedded in my in my brain. This go around, I wanted to watch it again. I was like, let me let's go ahead and watch it all the way. So I got 48 minutes in, and then my wife comes in, it's like, what are you doing? I said, watching, you know, watching the Fight Club. And then I said, do you remember this? 'Cause she bought the the movie for me years ago. And the the the anniversary or the special edition version. So she bought that version for me, but she saw it with me, but she just watched it just 'cause I was watching the film. She wasn't really into it. She like, yeah, there's like a crazy guy or something like that. She you're like, you're like,

Casey G. Smith.: But you're like, hmm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: I said, I paused. I said, um. I will rewind this, only for you.

Casey G. Smith.: Hmm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: But you have to watch the whole film. And so, I I was at 48.

Casey G. Smith.: With love and patience.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes. I started all the way over. I was like, no, you got to watch this thing. Because if that's all you remember then you you forgot a whole bunch of stuff.

Casey G. Smith.: Right, yeah, yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, it was like a crazy guy and fighting. That's all I remember. We're starting over. So I started.

Casey G. Smith.: That's that's like a trailer's worth of of info. Yeah, that's that's good that you started over then.

Reginald Titus Jr.: I was like, all right, let's start this over. I can't I can't do it like that. And so we watched the movie over again. And with different eyes, you know, we're older now, so, um, there's a lot more, we got a lot more experiences in life. Also, you know, sometimes I look at like conspiracy theory stuff and there's like some of that stuff in the film. Yeah, she got a lot more out of it this time.

Casey G. Smith.: Okay.

Reginald Titus Jr.: She she didn't realize like how much

Casey G. Smith.: How layered it is?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, like how many layers were on this.

Casey G. Smith.: So speaking of of of what's what's in there, obviously, this is this this film is based on a book.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yep.

Casey G. Smith.: Have you have you made any endeavors to ever check out the book or anything like that?

Reginald Titus Jr.: I didn't. I did, um, I know the graphic novel, Fight Club 2 came out. What was it? 2015 or 16?

Casey G. Smith.: Really?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah. It continues on I think.

Casey G. Smith.: The graphic novel out of it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Um, it continues with his life. I think he's like popping pills to suppress

Casey G. Smith.: Tyler.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah.

Casey G. Smith.: Huh.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And he has he's married, he's got a kid now, so things are different.

Casey G. Smith.: That is a fascinating premise.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Mhm.

Casey G. Smith.: That that is a fascinating premise. Now trying knowing knowing that it's a duality, trying to trying to suppress it. You know, the first film being about having to address it ultimately and knowing that that's a part of him. And then now the the the struggle. It's it's a one thing I I made note of is that this is a little bit of a Jekyll and Hyde kind of story, especially if you if you go back to the original, technically it's called Gekyll and Hyde. You go back to the original, there are some fascinating elements uh when you see the perspective of him just not realizing that he's becoming this monster. But um this this it got me kind of interested in checking out the maybe checking out the book or maybe an audio version of the book. Because, you know, obviously there's going to be a whole lot that's not in there.

Reginald Titus Jr.: True.

Casey G. Smith.: Um but yeah, I'm glad I'm glad the misses had a chance to to revisit it as well.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, so I watched that again, really enjoyed it, you know, enjoyed it again. I got, you know, the same out of it, but it's um I think I'm not as into it as I was, you know, young 18, 19-year-old masculinity, just like fighting, just like, this is what I, this is life. You know, rebelling, you know, trying to figure your way out in in the world. And they, you know, kind of say that, I don't know if another woman is, you know, the answer, you know, as they kind of doing their little thesis statements in the film.

Casey G. Smith.: Sure, and even talking about like kind of the nihilism, the kind of doing away with materialism and uh and which which which those are fascinating concepts that they touch on in the in the film in in themes of kind of just stripping things away and and getting down to even elements of identity.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Which can go into themes, themes of the film, you know, some of the themes, uh anti-consumerism, freedom, sadomasochism. And uh dispelling modern masculinity. So, that's kind of some of the things that I got out of it. And I actually had to look sadism, saydisim and masochism. And then that's a word I'm like, oh, okay. And it seems like that's the thing that Fincher's into, right?

Casey G. Smith.: Well, yeah, so remember when we talked about Panic Room, you know, when he when he talked about uh Jared Leto and and when they set him on fire in the sunseat that he that he he did a lot of his own stunts in there and he was like, he's my kind of masochist, you know. And when you watch quite a few of his films, he does have these scenes where, you know, there's some extreme, just think about now some extreme violence, whether it's Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, um whether it's whether it's the I mean the rape scene that comes from the book, which is, you know, pretty graphic, but also Daniel Craig later on with a bag around his head, um in that scene, it's just I mean, there's always like just pretty particularly violent scenes. Um Gone Girl with the with Neil Patrick Harris.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh man.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. Sorry, spoilers all over, ladies and gentlemen.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes, indeed.

Casey G. Smith.: We didn't tell you up front, we talk spoilers here in all manners. So I I should be more careful and cautious when talking about other other films. So my my bad on that up front, but as far as with uh this film, Fight Club, yeah, there will be spoilers.

Reginald Titus Jr.: There will be blood. So yeah, so one is you hopefully I'm getting the the uh what do you call it correct?

Casey G. Smith.: Sadomasochism.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, yeah, so sadism, right, is you get pleasure at somebody else being hurt. And masochism is you uh get pleasure of yourself being hurt.

Casey G. Smith.: Okay.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And then sometimes, this could be in a sexual way.

Casey G. Smith.: Ah. So even people who um

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay.

Casey G. Smith.: So it's not always specifically or explicitly sexual in nature. Any kind of. So even so even in okay, so even within the the fighting itself, obviously, it's it's a form of well, both, yeah, the sadism and the and the masochism.

Reginald Titus Jr.: All right. That makes a whole lot of sense. I mean, I contextually, I I knew when it what those words were used, but as far as the specific definitions.

Casey G. Smith.: Okay.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, I had to break it down. So okay, why is this? Why is he using it? Okay, I see it. Some of the conspiracy theories coming along with this was this was like in 1999 and all that. A lot of people online were specifically when like the World Trade when all that stuff went down, the the two towers. And then they use a scene of Edward Norton and what's her name? Helena?

Casey G. Smith.: Helena, mhm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Helena. Uh when they're holding hands and they're looking out the window and then they see the two towers kind of going down.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, I thought about that.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And then the scene right before that, when Edward Norton's in his chair and then Brad Pitt's looking at his watch, he said, we're at Ground Zero. Like, ooh, it's kind of, you know, like going back and he's saying that specifically, we're at Ground Zero. He's looking at his watch. And, you know, people were kind of like attaching like these conspiracy theories with this. It's like, okay, maybe.

Casey G. Smith.: So, you know, when I when I did see the towers fall in, I was like, huh? Hmm. What? But then they mentioned that again, like that these are attack, obviously like credit bureaus. And they mentioned like even when they made the digital versions of these different buildings that some actually were different just like corporate, like images of different like corporate buildings. I I forget what they called those towers, um, what company they were related to. But um, but yeah, I think they were related to a specific company. But also even the van that they had, that the white van that had the bomb in it at the bottom of the parking lot. They specifically wanted it to be a throwback to The First World Trade. Yeah, the first World Trade Center bombing. And so it's it's it is fascinating to see some of those connections, but even from the uh kind of the anti-consumerism aspect, some of the different companies and logos they're able to use like Pepsi and Starbucks. Yeah. They I guess maybe even Krispy Kreme they kind of showed up in there. But even like what They was in there, yeah, what they would allow them to do and show. Uh and who was kind of game to be like, oh yeah, we don't really, you know, we don't really care. Um versus who, you know, maybe wouldn't be cool with that. It's very interesting to see who would be, you know, okay, yeah, you know, speak speak your your truth, you know, to, you know, what you think is going on, but But even mentioned the impact of Columbine. Like the line that Edward Norton delivers to his boss, when he finds the Fight Club manifesto in the printer.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right, right.

Casey G. Smith.: And he's like, well, you know, you should be, you know, careful and you know, you know, it might, you know, blow to a guy who might, you know, come into the office with a, you know, with an assault rifle. And then that he has and I'm like, well, and he said, you know, before Columbine, you know, with I think with test that that like, you know, would played up and got a lot, you know, gotten a laugh. But then afterwards, like, it was, you know, totally totally different. Very uncomfortable. It became a very uncomfortable thing. It's just different events just changed perceptions pretty quickly.

Reginald Titus Jr.: True that. Some Easter eggs. Um this we watched it on DVD. So, there's a Blu-ray version. I I definitely want to get the Blu-ray.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, I've been thinking about that too after seeing it. I'm like, this would probably look.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, on the Blu-ray when you pop it in, I saw this on YouTube, when you pop the Blu-ray in, there's uh there was a movie called uh Never Been Kissed with

Casey G. Smith.: Drew Barrymore.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes. So that menu pops up on this Fight Club.

Reginald Titus Jr.: What?

Casey G. Smith.: What?

Reginald Titus Jr.: For like maybe 15 seconds. And then it's like and people online were like, I was pissed. When I first put this in, I was pissed 'cause they they turned it off. A lot of people like just turned it off like, they screwed up. They gave me the wrong Blu-ray. And then like after like 15 seconds, it starts glitching. And then it goes into the IKEA uh shot.

Casey G. Smith.: Oh wow. That's crazy.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So Fight Club, dude. And there's some on the DVD menu on just the the yeah, the regular DVD. Um I think they messed with the FBI warning on

Casey G. Smith.: They do. Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: They do. I'm like, what? Oh, it starts early. Well it's pretty it's pretty ingenious. I'm like, man, they even yeah, I I appreciated that that extra touch.

Casey G. Smith.: It just that's smart.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And it just kind of goes with Fincher's style, you know, with his title sequences. Again, with the packaging and just the time that he puts into the menus, it's just carries on throughout.

Casey G. Smith.: It's like entertainment throughout every every touchpoint. Like you are you are being brought into that world. From the moment you pick it up to the moment you pop it in, you're you're being drawn in into that world.

Filmmaking Techniques & Production Insights

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes sir. Did you notice the um the shot when they're like erasing the movies, uh the VHS in the you know, during Project Mayhem when they're in the like the Blockbuster store or whatever it is, and they pull out that device and they're erasing all the VHS tapes.

Casey G. Smith.: Okay.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Did you notice there was an Alien movie?

Casey G. Smith.: Hmm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: There was an Alien movie on like one of the shelves.

Casey G. Smith.: Really?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, it was all shade. You know, Fincher's like makes you makes you makes you think about Alien when they're Alien, yeah. He didn't say anything about it too on that scene.

Casey G. Smith.: So great. That's it that's smart.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Like dang.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. Uh, that's that's funny. That's real funny.

Reginald Titus Jr.: One of the point, oh, the actual commentary. So, uh, what do you think about Fincher on this commentary?

Reginald Titus Jr.: He's a younger Fincher.

Casey G. Smith.: It's not to me it doesn't come across any different than his other commentaries. Same same level of energy. If Fincher's his commentaries are very informal. Like he he jumps in and gets right to business. He doesn't introduce himself. He doesn't he doesn't sign on, he doesn't sign off. He just goes right. He doesn't say, hi, this is David Fincher. So that's why they have a little voice over before. In this commentary, you're going to hear David Fincher.

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's why they had to spend some money to get that guy to say that.

Casey G. Smith.: Right. You know, 'cause, you know, Fincher's not going to introduce himself. He's like, you should know by now who I am. And so he just he just goes in. But he always gives interesting tidbits and it's it's always just, you know, he's always going to talk about different, you know, support and challenges that they had during the making of the film. And again, with this film, they had a lot of support. Always appreciate Fincher's commentary because he comes across as a as a guy that I think would be very interesting to have a actual face-to-face conversation with.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right.

Casey G. Smith.: And that he seems to he seems really knowledgeable. Like he knows a little bit about everything or he takes the time to research things because clearly he's he's meticulous and methodical in everything. Yes, yes, OCD for sure. But he's always has a always has a little bit of knowledge about everything. So when he speaks to it, you know, I'm like, okay, this guy, he's done his he's done his homework. So I always always appreciate that aspect. And then I'm always just blown away by and feel bad for how many people will have to do so many takes. Which he seems to have some sympathy towards. He's like, oh, yeah, we really put him to the ringer and they come back for the pickups and I just like, ah, just, you know, I feel bad, but you know, we had to get it done. And so, you know, he he's like hitting you with a a velvet glove. Like, hey, we got to get it done. Yeah, but but pushes through and he gives props to, you know, to everybody that helps pull off these things. So he doesn't he doesn't come across as like arrogant with that. He's just he he comes across very real. And at the at the end of the day, he seems like he's being just very honest and straightforward. Like he's not a he's not a BS-er by by any stretch and he he enjoys his craft. So, uh I always pick up some interesting tidbits. What what did you think, Reginald?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Same, you know, same David Fincher. Not as informative as not as informative as the more mature uh David Fincher. Now, he seems like he packs in a lot um in his commentaries. He feels a little bit younger, you know, in the commentary, but still the same, you know, he's you know, he's giving you information, letting you know what happened and and kind of giving you a little insight from a directing standpoint.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, there are some spaces in between with his commentary. There's a little bit of some where it's like the movie's kind of playing and then he then he'll pop back in. And that's why, you know, I started listening to the uh the actor commentary with with with Brad Pitt and Edward Norton and Fincher's in that is in that too. It's like the three of them are together. And then Helena Bonham Carter Carter is like is by herself. Um giving commentary and then it'll cut back to them. And then maybe even another one, it may even be one with Edward by himself, 'cause sometimes he's saying things.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Dude, Ed Norton.

Casey G. Smith.: And no one's and no one's responding. He's like, saying something that should be funny. And I'm like, I don't hear Brad Pitt or

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah.

Casey G. Smith.: I'm like, maybe he maybe also did one by himself and then did one with the with the three of them.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, it comes off like they're tired of Ed Norton. He's like, always talking. He knows everything 'cause he graduated from Yale, right? Uh so.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, he he is the one main one talking during the during those commentaries. He's giving some interesting stuff. He's main one talking. And then Brad Pitt's just back back and chill. Oh yeah, we did that. That was that was pretty cool. Yeah, yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: He's kind of chaming in here and there. He's too cool for school. He's too cool for school.

Casey G. Smith.: He gets some insightful things here and there in what I've heard so far, but he's kind of just, yeah, you know, we when they do this this way, you know, I really wanted to go here now. He mentioned he mentioned that when he's on, like he said he's he's I think maybe he was contrasting himself and and Edward's style in acting that when Edward is, you know, like super meticulous and prepared and all kinds of ways. But he's like, he kind of goes with kind of the moment of the day. So if he's in the scene, he's feeling it and he goes, when I'm on, man, I'm I'm on. He goes, but when I'm off, then I'm off. And it's like, just different different styles.

Reginald Titus Jr.: What I think I know about Brad Pitt's like in some of his characters, he's like, he likes chewing food. And he knows on the payphones like dude just eating food, like, what?

Casey G. Smith.: I was just going to say that. Who is this?

Reginald Titus Jr.: He did the same thing in um Oceans 11. He just always eating something. Like, this guy here, I don't know, it's like just one of those character quirks. He likes to put in his his character.

Casey G. Smith.: So here's a like a, I don't know, a public service now, public service announcement. I don't know how people used payphones back in the day.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Why?

Casey G. Smith.: They seem disgusting. They seem just absolutely disgusting.

Reginald Titus Jr.: They are. I used to use them all the time. Man, I I think back I'm like, man, there's very few times where I ever had to use one. Get your wipe But then quote in, get the biz. Man, yeah, I just, man, when we we did when we, you know, we did that one scene we shot years ago, and and I remember just like, I was like, I'm sorry, do I need to actually touch this thing? Um That was that was I was like, wait. Wait a minute. Yeah, that's just it's public. This is this is quite public. Yes. Anyway, I just I'm I'm glad we have cell phones now. Personal. Personal. Devices.

Reginald Titus Jr.: It's hilarious.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: It's kind of disgusting.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, that would date it. That that's one of the things that for sure date the film.

Casey G. Smith.: Hmm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: We need to write numbers down.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, one of the points is uh misinterpreted jokes. So, they were trying to do the liner notes and it and it involved IKEA and was it IKEA and the Dust Brothers? They said don't have a stick of furniture and of IKEA between the both of them. Something like that. It was taking kind of taking a jab at IKEA, but if you don't know the inside joke, if you haven't seen the film, it could be taken like way out of context and could cause legal issues. Let that kind of just be a point that um everybody is not going to watch the film. Whatever your film is, a lot of people may not watch it, you know, or be on the inside. So, some of the things you may think are funny may cause legal issues. And so when you're kind of disparaging a company, it it just be on the lookout for that.

Casey G. Smith.: That's that's true. That that's a risk that you you have to take what may be funny between you and your network of people and your circle, may may fly with others. Which I mean, I think at the end of the day, you you to some it's it's a fine line. You definitely don't think with certain things comedy-wise. I think you know when you're pushing it. So you might want to test it with some people who are outside of your, you know, your circle, who may also walk in that other space to say, hey, is this is this too much? Sometimes you might want to push it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right.

Casey G. Smith.: You know, no nothing ventured nothing gained. But but yeah, in this film, you know, they had obviously, you know, this is a studio film. And so they had producers and execs who were giving feedback. And they have the MPAA. I mean, they, you know,

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh man.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, all kinds of times they had to make make adjustments. But definitely they they had concerns over that. Brad Pitt mentioned in the actor's commentary that there's a a joke that he made, uh, a joke that he made during the scene with him and Norton sitting at the at the table at the bar when they when they're I guess the second time that they're meeting. I can't remember what it was, but he he he thought he thought it would land. He thought it would be funny, because, but he said, but it never lands, man. He goes, it crushes me, man. It never lands.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah, happens.

Casey G. Smith.: Speaking of jokes, remember the scene with Marla and Tyler and Ed Norton. Um when um Brad Pitt's talking to Ed Norton, he said, you got some messed up friends, but he didn't say that. And the stuff that came out of her mouth, and then they cut to them both being in bed and she's like, I haven't been like like that since I was in grade school. Yeah. So originally, the joke was, I want to have your abortion. I want to have your abortion. That was that was that was the original line that they had. Yeah. I want to have your abortion. Yikes. You know, that's some dark comedy. You know, you know, one of the women, one of the producers said, hey, can you change that anything? Change it to anything.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Anything.

Casey G. Smith.: All right. And then uh Fincher you like, hey, whatever we choose, we get to keep that. Yes. Whatever you got. Okay, you got it.

Reginald Titus Jr.: You got to be careful with those desperation bargains. Yes, and open-ended bargains.

Casey G. Smith.: So they changed it from the abortion to haven't been screwed like that since grade school. And that gets more laughs. And she said, can you please put the abortion joke back in there?

Reginald Titus Jr.: That's rock and a hard place. That's a rock and a hard place. Yeah, but he said, like, like, when she said when she delivered that line, like she delivered it so perfectly that literally, like, that scene, they can they they had to cut it real tight because you could literally only go a couple frames more before the camera started shaking and the whole crew like just started just cracking up laughing.

Casey G. Smith.: I know they had a blast doing that film. Had to.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Mhm.

Casey G. Smith.: But they said, hey, like that it the line was just delivered so well.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Wow. So there speaking of that, like the camera shaking, there's a shot um when Tyler Brad Pitt, he's giving orders, you know, giving homework assignments, start a fight with somebody and lose. And then so they're doing like a montage of people starting fights and trying to get people to beat them up. And people are scared to do it. So it was a scene when a guy shoots water at a pastor. He's in the priest outfit and everything. And then he's like, hey, and then he slaps his Bible on the ground and starts spraying that. He's like, sir, that is not necessary. And the cameraman like the shaking. You can see it. You can and they they kept it because it's a good shot. It's a good but the cameraman is like moving. I was like, oh, I didn't even notice that until Fincher pointed it out.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. Um.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Mhm.

Casey G. Smith.: That dude is trying to hold it together. Those scenes were pretty funny. Like the trying to literally trying to to start a fight. I yeah, those were those were

Reginald Titus Jr.: And the soundtrack is awesome, like the score. I don't know if like the score and the soundtrack if it's the same, but I'll just say the score, with the Dust Brothers are doing, you know, as they go into these different montages and changing it up. It's like, it just goes. And so it's like a little playful tune while this montage is going on. Or the part when Ed Norton confronts Marla and he's like, hey, you're a you're a person you need to get out of here because you're messing up my you're a tourist or whatever. And then like the tone changes to like. It's like, man, these guys are on it.

Casey G. Smith.: Well, even with the way all that is is is cut, uh, from the time she gets introduced into the groups. Yeah. And then like the way we just, you know, pan back over to him and him just kind of looking at her. And then when each group you go to and she's she's just there, like, like nothing's wrong. Like, I should I have as much of a right to be here. And she and then every one, she's always smoking, right? Always. She's always smoking. Yeah. They mention anything about her smoking? Like, was her They did actually. What did they say? So, actually, this actually came out more in the actor's commentary, uh, where I think I think Norton said that, you know, I thought that maybe doing the film would maybe help her maybe to to quit smoking because she would have to smoke so much in some of these scenes. And then in her commentary, she says that, you know, I got paid to to smoke, you know, in in a film. Like, that's no, that's that's fantastic. Like, I I I loved it. You know, Norton thought she went from like two packs a day to like three packs a day. Like maybe increased.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And it was like always a fresh cigarette too. It was like like it just got lit.

Casey G. Smith.: And you know, multiple take Fincher, you know that, I mean, who knows how much. And again, she's a she's an amazing singer. She has an amazing voice. And so, but that's just Yeah. So she was singing. Yeah. How those scenes are edited in addition to the music, it's it's it's it's pretty powerful. When he does finally confront her. They also they even said that at one point, when he initially is she starts showing up in his world and he there's a shot of him on his bed like like trying to go to sleep. And he's got one hand behind his back and his arm is kind of laying over over his body. He's like, and in initial there's some takes where he was trying to like, uh, please himself, if we if you will. But that he he hates her so much that he can't even get that satisfaction. He's trying and he he's he's he's thinking of her in a physical sense, but he's so upset that she is taking away his, you know, his solace and his sleep that he that that doesn't even work for him. Uh and then but but then this is where, you know, thematically that Brad Pitt and Norton mentioned that it's kind of one it's kind of one of those things where when you meet somebody that's so much like you and if you don't really like yourself, then you'll project that self-hate onto them because they are so much alike. So when she comes in the scene like, like in instead of him honestly, they'd be a technically should and could be maybe a good match for each other, maybe potentially. But he is so averse to her and it's so perfect match. They're doing the same thing, tourists. Exactly. Why couldn't they do this together? But he's so he's so damaged. Yeah. That he comes up like and she even says this in commentary, she thinks that he comes up with Tyler to to be that Uber masculine way to even approach her for the sake of a relationship of Mike. Interesting. Did you notice the subliminal Tyler Durdens popping up in the movie? Yeah. Yeah. And the first time I watched it, I don't know if I caught them. Because it's all can be one of those things where if you're watching, if you turn away for whatever reason, Yeah. Because when I went to the commentary and I was watching it, I I the ones that I saw earlier, I I missed because I looked at I looked down at something. But once I saw the very first one, I'm like, okay, there are multiple ones of these. And I just knew they were coming. And yeah, I I spotted them just you know, again and again and again. And then when they, you know, talk about his other job where he's cutting things together and putting things in cartoons. I'm like, okay. And of course, at the very very end of the of the film, you know, there's the full frontal. Yeah, like goddess. That was a good one. That was a good joke.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Zing.

Casey G. Smith.: But yeah, I I did I definitely noticed those, which is a pretty brilliant way to introduce this psychosis, this this dual personality that it's like slowly blips of it. Um and yeah, and the fact that that, you know, one appears right as he's confronting her as well, right? Isn't there there's I think there's one that that happens then? Or either either once she's first introduced or right as Yeah, the one's I remember. He goes and confront her. The ones I remember is when he's talking about his job and the copiers is going on. It blips in. And then when he's at the doctor's office and then in the hallway, the doctor talks about, you know, when he's asking for the pills, Yeah, real pain, you should go to that. Until he's saying that Tyler bumps in. And then when Marla, when she leaves and she goes down like a an aisle. She's going down like a dark um alleyway. Whatever scene that was. I I I don't remember what what they were.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Okay. She's going down an alleyway.

Casey G. Smith.: Is after I think he initially confronts her, no? And she's uh and she's there they go outside and they're walking and then she goes to like walk away from them. Yeah, whatever when she like uh Ed Norton's in the left of the frame. She's in the far right, but she's going down an aisle. Right. She's going down an alleyway. And then we're kind of like, where is she going? And then it blips again. Yeah. And then we see him fully when he's on the airport ride. And he like, okay, it's Brad Pitt. Okay. Which is yeah, that's so crazy, man. Like, the fact that he's having these and it makes you wonder sometimes if he's having full conversations versus, you know, just thinking, like, on the on the airplane, like, did he have a full conversation by himself on the airplane? Or was it all in his head? Or did he had he not really woken up just yet and just dreamt that he woke up and this was a battle the conversation in his mind? Um yeah. Psychologically it gets deep. It's real. Um another point is discovering talent. So, Fincher discovered Meat Loaf while watching a VH1 Behind the Scenes movie.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Really? I knew you said you saw him in a in a film, but I didn't know that it was a behind the scenes.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. So he was like, this guy's like a sweet a sweet guy, you know, he's got he's a bigger guy, got the long hair and everything, but comes off like as a sweet guy. What would be perfect for Bob. So you never know where you will find your inspiration that perfect character actor. It's fascinating that uh, you know, when Meat Loaf arrived, 'cause Norton wasn't wasn't, you know, sure about having uh him play the role. But then when he when he came in and he kind of went with the soft air and kind of higher pitched tone because you know, he didn't have testicles. But it he like they they like couldn't stop laughing. And uh and he did that. He did that movie where he embraced Edward. And then like brought his head into his bosom. He said like that, like that, like so like they offered him the officially offered him the the role that same day. Uh and again, I did not realize that was Meat Loaf, uh until they mentioned. I'm like, holy smokes, that is Meat Loaf. And he's actually shorter than Edward Norton. So when he's actually embracing him, he's actually standing either he's either he has platform shoes or he's standing on something to get that shot. 'Cause Norton's actually taller than Meat Loaf in in real life.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Got it. Perfect. That's funny.

Casey G. Smith.: In real life.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Um Meat Loaf. That's like the worst name. I tried to look him up like on Google, you type in Meat Loaf. It's just like all these pictures of like this dirty meat loaf, but you got to put Meat Loaf singer.

Casey G. Smith.: Now, were you familiar with him before? You were?

Reginald Titus Jr.: I only know about Meat Loaf because of Beavis and Butt-Head.

Casey G. Smith.: Oh, really?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yeah.

Casey G. Smith.: So, he had made that comeback when I was in, oh, man, I was in junior high. 'Cause I didn't know I didn't know who he was until then, but he had that song, you know, I would do anything for love, but I won't do that. Like that was his comeback. Uh, 'cause he had been big in the late '70s, early '80s. You know, he had his Bat Out of Hell album, all that kind of stuff. And, um, I think he's in he's in the Rocky Horror Picture Show as well, I believe. He has a a role in that. He plays a character. I think he comes in on a motorcycle or something like that. He's got he he has a role in the Rocky Horror Picture Show.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Interesting.

Casey G. Smith.: But uh, but yeah, so that was his his his his comeback. His his introduction to the next generation. A lot of '70s uh rockers, you know, whether it was Queen with Bohemian Rhapsody, like in the, you know, in the mid-'90s kind of made some comebacks. Aerosmith made a made a comeback during that time. It was just a it was a thing that was that was happening.

Reginald Titus Jr.: It was a thing. Yeah. I watched Beavis and Butt-Head in in between. Like, I was obsessed with that freaking cartoon. Oh, you're not the only one, brother. And in between, you know, the different sequences, of course, they're playing like heavy metal and all that stuff. And that's how I was getting introduced to all these crazy acts. And then when Meat Loaf came on, then Beavis was like, Meat Loaf! And so, yeah. So just like, dang, like, GWAR, like, all that stuff just stuck in my head.

Casey G. Smith.: Oh, GWAR. They would they would go nuts for GWAR. Yes. GWAR. Oh man.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Things we look at.

Casey G. Smith.: Liquid television. Oh. There we go. Anybody there?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Aeon Flux. Oh man, that's brilliant. Dog Boy.

Casey G. Smith.: Oh man.

Reginald Titus Jr.: I bought the whole Aeon Flux like cartoon set on I got it on DVD.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah, man. Aeon Flux for an adolescence. Yeah. Yikes. Moving right along. Moving right along.

Behind-the-Scenes & Industry Perspectives

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, having a good producer is crucial because Fincher was talking about having a producer walk the executives through the dailies of the film because if there's like a certain tone, like the way that um the voice over, it's a he he used Sardonic. So Sardonic sense of humor in in the voice over. And so for that to be portrayed, somebody has to walk the executives through this, especially if they haven't read the book or if they kind of know where they're kind of stay true to that tone. One of the producers is going to have to walk them through that. So, having a good producer that knows what's going on, that's in on the inside jokes and knows the material in and out is very helpful, especially when you're working with a studio.

Casey G. Smith.: Exactly, 'cause especially after they had shot, you know, very the the early part of the of the shoot were the interest groups, uh the specialty groups. And so to have several weeks of shooting and if somebody's looking at the dailies and they're like, what's that? What the hell's going on here? You know, why are you guys just spending time at this location? Where's where's the action and and where's the where's the dialogue?

Reginald Titus Jr.: Right.

Casey G. Smith.: Well, here's the thing. There's a lot of voice over and and exposition that's going to happen that sets everything up. So yeah, you would definitely need a producer to be able to explain that to the execs. So, yes, kudos.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Yes. Producer. There's a scene where Fincher specifically talks about shooting with two cameras. And it's a scene in the bar when Brad Pitt and Edward Norton, they're kind of going through their different philosophies. Ed Norton's talking about, man, I lost all my furniture. I spent so much time in trying to do that. Then Brad Pitt's like, darn and it's all gone, you know.

Casey G. Smith.: Hmm.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And you can kind of see their philosophies are competing with with each other and just contrasting. But it the way they shot it, it allows them to overlap and allow them to freely just play with their characters.

Casey G. Smith.: And they did multiple, of course, this is Fincher. They did like 30 plus takes of that. But yeah, that two camera setup really allowed them to be able to to flow because they they all kind of worked on the scene together. Uh and and wrote different portions of it and Fincher kind of just let them go to establish and hit the the right tone because that that scene is pretty crucial. Obviously, it's important when they first meet. But now that Edward has chosen to actively engage with Tyler, them confronting themselves in their philosophies and kind of it's it's the beginning of of Edward's kind of, I guess, his his break. He's beginning to reject, obviously, his his current life. And they're feeling the need for more and this is Tyler's chance to begin to kind of plant those those seeds.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Practical blood versus digital blood. So, you know, there's a scene where Brad Pitt, um, they're he's about to explain the rules of Fight Club in this basement, lose Tavern or whatever. And then Lou comes in. What are you doing? He's like, what are you doing? And then he's like, I'm Lou and then he beats up, you know, Brad Pitt's character. And then the blood is just dripping, dripping down. And then Brad Pitt, you know, grabs Lou and he's on the ground and he just all this blood is just dripping from Brad Pitt's face onto Lou the character. Yeah. And they said and he said they did this for like five hours.

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. And that actor that actor who played Lou, after the five hours, he was not happy. He like refused to do any more takes. Just, you know, again, that is just Fincher's uh

Reginald Titus Jr.: And it's so quick. That scene. Yeah, like the especially specifically the shots with the blood dripping on the him again, that's that masochism stuff, you know, it's

Casey G. Smith.: And the sadism.

Reginald Titus Jr.: So, Fincher's though, he's sitting there torturing people. He's like, I like this. I like this.

Casey G. Smith.: Hmm. Right.

Reginald Titus Jr.: But this like the way this movie is built and the way it feels, it feels like grounded in reality. Even though it's absurd, it's it feels like it's tangible. We know Fincher now does digital blood, you know, Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, the blood dripping down that's it's digital. Even in the Zodiac, a lot of that blood was digital, the stab wounds and all that. And we know he prefers to do that now because he doesn't want to go through doing all those takes, changing clothes. But I it's something about that practical blood versus the digital blood that is just it feels real and visceral.

Casey G. Smith.: I think if you don't know, then it's okay. I think it's the sake of what what kind of what kind of scene is it going to be. If something where it's going to like kind of soak is one thing, but where it needs to drip and splash or fling, then yeah, practical might be the way to go. 'Cause 'cause clearly the way it's just I mean, it's just, yeah, the the the the syrupy nature of of blood being caked and and and beginning to kind of dry and and harden. Yeah, that that kind of comes comes through.

Reginald Titus Jr.: And then it just it just looks more real. It just looks brutal. And the shot with um Ed Norton when he's beating himself up and he's like crawling on the floor and then he's holding his nose and it's like squirting out, you know, the Oh, man, it's just

Casey G. Smith.: And it's and it's yeah, and this film is a is it's a it's a literally it's a dark uh it's a darker yeah, film. You can see it in the eyes of people, like just the dark shadows. You don't really see the lights in their eyes. Brad Brad Pitt mentioned that to him, especially during the opening scene when they're uh when they when they in the rooftop um right as Pitt is pulling the gun out of out of Norton's mouth. Brad Pitt mentioned in the commentary, he's like, man, this is this is this like is dark. He goes, this is a really like dark-looking film. And she's like, yeah, you know, I think that sometimes like eyes are overlit. And so I wanted to kind of take that away. Uh and Brad mentioned a couple of other times, wow, this is this is really dark. And yeah, there's like, yeah, yeah.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Oh man.

Casey G. Smith.: And yeah, that's Fincher's style. A lot of his a lot of his stuff is dark like that. And you you know, what is it? House of Cards. Um Kevin Spacey and all that stuff. Oh yeah, the first. Like, do they even use lights? Or are they just using practical lights from the lamps? It feels like they're just using the practical lights from the lamps. Yeah, the first season is yeah. I I forgot he had done a lot of the first episodes of House of Cards.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Details, details. So, there's a scene we were talking about Ed Norton and his boss and kind of going back and forth. Um, there's like they're in profile shot. So Ed Norton's on the left frame, talking to the boss to his right. And the boss is in the right frame looking left. And there's a thermostat 'cause they had to come back and reshoot. So when you cut to Norton's scene, I think the thermostat's like either white or black. I can't remember. And then when they cut to the boss, the thermostat in the background has changed colors. And since he was doing things a lot, you know, more things practical, I think now with that mistake, that continuity mistake, 'cause I didn't notice it. I didn't notice it until he pointed it out. These days, he would just replace it digitally. Quickly. He would just, you know, digitally change that thing and correct it 'cause it just doesn't go with David Fincher and him being OCD, he would cut that out.

Casey G. Smith.: Mhm. He made a statement during the commentary he said, he goes, a lot of movies are about effing things up to go back and fix them. He said because as you initially are kind of shooting and you got everything planned and you got pre-production and and and obviously with him a lot of pre-visuals and blocking and and even rehearsals and everything's like all kind of real precious kind of to you initially as you go in. And then once you've gone through the process and you've made things you've you've you've made some mistakes. Now you're like, okay, all right. Now we need to just kind of get this done and and just now, now I'm not thinking of the creation of it, but the maybe just the just the solution of the okay, how do we how do we fix this because now there is a an existing maybe problem or puzzle. Okay, how do we fix this thing? Um basically saying, you know, trial there's trial and error on every in every set, every movie, every film. And yeah, so yeah, his quote again, a lot of movies about everything's up to go back and fix them.

Reginald Titus Jr.: There's a scene with um Jared Leto. Uh it's um and he's having a fight with uh Edward Norton. Edward Norton's jealous, um because he's getting more attention from Tyler Durden. And then, you know, Ed Norton just knocks the guy on the ground and he's obviously gone limp. He puts his arm up. He's gone limp. He's done. But he just keeps whaling on his face. And it's like a close-up just seeing fist to face like concrete. Oh, man, it's it's it's horrible. But um the I guess they're waiting for the MPAA to get back to him to see if it was going to pass. Mhm. And they said it just spent a lot of time on this scene. They they wanted to like something cut out of it because it was just too long. So what he did was he started shooting the reactions of the people. Right. So the people uh the guys in the crowd are like kind of taken aback. They start walking toward, you know, some were disgusted, some of the guys throw up in a can, trash can. And these are the reactions of the people. And it turns out with that scene being taken those scenes out of the graphic nature and just kind of showing the reactions. People are actually more disturbed.

Casey G. Smith.: More uncomfortable. Yeah. That's a the yeah, the reaction. People reacting is I mean, that's that's what acting is is is about. You know, how people react to to each other is so powerful. And that that does make it more disturbing. When you see them going from Yeah, yeah. And you and these are guys in a Fight Club, right? They they're beating each other up every day. And for them to be like, what's going on, Mhm. That means something's wrong. And it's also it's it's but it's also so paramount to where the story is going because it's all about things are going too far. You know, things are going to the next plateau where people are or in the person, the guy who made the rules now is breaking them. Where now his his alter ego where Tyler says to him, oh, you know, he says he makes a comment about kind of, you know, you know, going, you know, too far, going.

Reginald Titus Jr.: Would you go, psycho boy?

Casey G. Smith.: Yeah. I'm like, that's not good. When you're when you're crazy alter ego is telling the the sane part of you, you're kind of crazy. Yeah, things are not going well. You that's that's you know, he's he's beginning to really lose it. He's totally beginning to lose it. And that's another element of the of the film that stood out to me this go around. When Edward Norton's character starts questioning Project Mayhem, Yeah. And they tell him, oh, the first rule of Project Mayhem, you don't you don't you don't ask questions. Yeah. And when you see how they're reacting to him, and this is before the reveal. Right. Now watching it the second time through, that just carries so much more weight as they as they look at him and as they respond and as they even if they they don't know if it's a test or what. Yeah. And as you as you, you know, especially once the um the smiley face with the with the flaming eyes that happens on TV and the news report comes out. And then when he looks to Tyler in the kitchen, but there's another guy like behind Tyler who's against the wall. And that guy thinks that that Edward Norton's character is looking at him. 'Cause I watched that guy's reaction. That guy kind of gets uncomfortable, kind of looks away a little bit. But he's Yeah. I'm like, oh, man, there's these these layers of insanity. Well done. So well done. So yeah, , that Yeah, going back and looking through that. Seeing how he's framed up with Brad Pitt a lot of times, they were not necessarily like close, they were just off a little bit, so that like Brad Pitt can almost be cut out of the scenes. Mhm. Um, again, how people were reacting to him, you know, Marla like is a concerned girlfriend, you know. Right. Initially, it's like, she's trying to figure out, again, what the heck is wrong with you. Yeah. And initially, the first time I watched it, I was like, I was like, what's wrong with her? For her. But then again, second time through, you're like, oh, it's him. This dude's nuts. Because he literally is running hot and cold to to her, you know, when she asked him to come over and check for the lump. And then she's asking him, what was that all about? You know, I'm like, he's like, what's doing? She's like, you got like extra food for him and stuff. She's got the things. I got you one also. He's like, no, I'm I'm fine. So, he comes across like a total jerk. I'm like, man, it's And that's pretty wonderful. I I really wonder how, again, all that how all that plays out when you're reading it. Because I mean, this this book is like it's made to like be visualized, especially when you're dealing with somebody who has somebody in there, you know, head. Like, so then you got these two voices. I would like to see the script. I want to I actually want to read the script, um, to see how they were able to pull this off if it was if you could tell by reading the script that this is how it was going to play out. Yeah. And even what changes they make because they Fincher mentioned that the the very first scene where they where they both meet for the first time on the airplane, that's not in the book. They actually, in the book, they actually meet on a uh at a nudist beach. But it was it but it was in the screenplay though. This version's in the screenplay. Even though it's not in the book, it's in the screenplay. That I don't know. Okay. I don't know when they made that change. I don't know if it's in the original screenplay or not. Um Brad Brad knew about it. He was like, oh, yeah, let's do it, you know. He's like, yeah, anything, whatever. I don't care. He's like, no no big deal. This level of um directing is like masterful because uh another movie sort of like that is the Chris Nolan movie, Memento? Yeah, kind of the Memento. So. That was more like changing the sequences. Inception? Um no, um even though those are great. Um, what's the one with the magicians? Oh, The Prestige. The Prestige. So, when you watch that movie, you watch it one way, but then after you find out what's going on, you go back and look at it, and you're the one being set up, you know, for the big magic trick or the Prestige. It's like, you watch it one way, but when you find out what's going on, you want to watch the movie again because you're looking at it with different eyes. And you see the layers throughout the film. Chris Nolan specifically said that about, you know, The Prestige. That's what he wanted to do is have layers of that. So, that commentary on The Prestige. Yes, I believe so. It is. Well, I'm just just asking. Inquiring minds want to know for future episodes. There we go. All right, all right. It's been a while since I've seen that one. Yeah, that one that one's brilliant. Yeah. That one's good. So that's what it remind me of, but you have to you have to be mas you have to be a master of your craft to pull that off. To make people want to watch the movie again. Mhm. Finding the tone in this particular one, it was kind of difficult when they were I guess they were testing this with different audiences to find it because they didn't know if they were supposed to take this seriously because it's grounded in reality, but the things that they're shooting is like absurd. Right. And so like what is the tone of this thing? And trying to explain that. And so that's why he said it was difficult to try to find that tone because it it is realistic, but it's absurd at the same time. So what is it? But I like the tone, whatever it is. I don't know what it is, but I like it. But I like it. It it is a it is a a very it's so different, man, because when when things are happening and then when it goes into the because it's so grounded, but then you have like these amazing effects that that that that add to the film and give it it but they also kind of heighten they kind of heighten the reality because it takes you in so close, you know, with with some of the different effects from, you know, what causes his kitchen his his apartment to explode. Oh yeah. Uh to coming out of the again the fear synapses of of of of synapses of his brain. Yeah, to panning down to the bottom of the the building that they're in to the other buildings where these bombs are at. It gives it this this interesting scope, but then at the same time you wonder, okay, you know, it's it's it's it's dark in nature from the from the the humor aspect and it's it's dramatic in other aspects. I wonder what genre it officially was was filed under. Action thriller. Yeah, see if there's something here on uh IMDB that was genre category on here. Drama. What? Not to say. Stop it. Okay, uh there was a scene. Oh, um shooting on the stage is easier. So when Ed Norton and the what did they call the crew? The people that are in people that are hazing that's part of their new crew. Oh, human sacrifices? You know, the people that they're hazing, the kind of be part of this Project Mayhem thing. I don't know if they had a name for these guys. Human sacrifices. Well, there's a scene when when he sees all their IDs or whatever and this is like human sacrifices. So I don't know if that was a different purpose or something that was there for a different purpose. Not those guys. Not those guys. Um the guys that are dressed in all black that are part of Project Mayhem. Sure, sure. They're calling them Project uh calling them human sacrifices. Well, when when Norton wakes up and and realizes that he's been Tyler for a while and he goes back to the house and he sees like all their all these drivers licenses. I assume that those are members of the crew. Oh, no, that was from uh remember the Asian guy that they took out the store. And those are the people that that's like part of his homework assignment. So like, Oh, targets? Yeah, targets. Got you, my bad. Yeah. 'Cause right before he goes into that store, Norton was like, what are you doing? He's getting out of human sacrifice. As he walks into the store. Okay, okay. My bad. And so those Yeah. So he's like, I'm going to keep your ID if you're not going to be a veterinarian. Those people that they've they've come across and and huh, okay, my bad. Then I don't know what they call those guys. I don't know. But uh but they're in a car. They're in the back seat with Ed Norton and Tyler, you know, they're they're fighting. And um it feels like it the the camera work and everything feels real, but it it kind of feels surreal at the same time. And the reason is because they shot it on the stage. I was wondering, I was like, something feels doesn't feel all the way real. And it turns out. We're driving in the traffic and all that and it's raining and Yeah. They tried to do it practically. They did. Yeah, it didn't it didn't work. Like they they had spent they spent, you know, a couple of days or whatever trying to do it practically and and going up and down the street with different kind of lighting. But it didn't. It's too much going on to try to do that. It didn't quite work. Yeah. So you can you can kind of feel it, but it still comes off well 'cause you know, they got the water splashing up. So it still feels real, but it it it's got a little bit of surrealism in it. If Fincher mentions that in that scene, like that's like the scene that's that's a little bit fantastical in the relationship between Tyler and Edward Norton's character because in in when the valet comes up and he he's looking at Norton saying telling him his car is ready, but it's Tyler that gets into the driver's seat and Norton goes into the passenger side. And so that that makes it really tough to distinguish between the two when you have again Tyler's character literally like kind of behind the wheel and Norton is the passenger. Maybe that's symbolic of saying that Tyler is in the driver's seat of Norton's mind or is beginning to to go that way. But then of course when the car crashes and flips over, it's Norton that comes out of the the driver's side and Tyler that comes out of the passenger side. But I don't know. But but Fincher mentioned that that's a little bit of a there's a little bit of a cheat having Tyler drive the car initially. Who knows. He's crazy. He can do whatever he wants to. Um and of course they were doing the sound mix at um Skywalker Ranch. And one of the guys while doing the sounds like, oh, it's a pity. Kind of talking to and David Fincher like, what, what? He's like, continuity, you know, talking about that. Fincher's like, well, just, you know, just keep watching and let me know what you think. Right. And so don't question the master. He knows what he's doing. The OCD master. Fincher mentions that with his film as a whole, this this film was one of his most enjoyable filmmaking experiences in the in in relation to, they said, this was the least he was like challenged as far as like by exact. Now maybe that's the role, maybe he had a really good producer like you mentioned earlier. But he said he had the least amount of like like maybe studio interference, uh even though this this film is complicated. Even there were some things they asked him to adjust, but they were fairly minor things. Most of the film, he shaved maybe up to like five minutes worth off of it. But he he was able to put pretty much what he wanted to into it. He even got extra time. Like the at one point they came to him and asked him, well, do you want more time to complete the film? And he got an extra like four to five weeks. Um and yeah, yeah, he got that he got that time and that uh I guess that money as well. But this was supposed to come out in the summer. And he did the he did the work too. You know, it's um when they found out that the book rights were sold to Fox, he wasn't sure if Fox was going to be the one, if they were going to be willing to do the film in like the same tone and everything. And after talking to them, he's like, hey, I would like to, you know, do a presentation uh with this. And I guess because he's, you know, he's battle-torn, you know, he's been in battle before with properties and things like that. And he's like, hey, I don't want this to be a long drawn-out thing. I'll do it. You don't pay me. Like, I guess what what would be the um the call, the development funds to develop it. Like, you know, don't pay me. And so he went with the the writer and they wrote the screenplay. And then attached or at least got the interest of Brad Pitt and that. Like, and with storyboards and all that stuff in the package. So, a year later, he drops on this like, hey, this is my vision for it. That's right. You know, you do that. Sure, whatever you want. Brad Pitt, cool. Yes. What do you want? You Brad Pitt, yeah. You know, you dropped that down, it's like, of course, you're going to get what you want. But if he didn't have that vision and the way he wanted to approach it, he probably would have had more problems. Yeah, doing that homework, man, uh beforehand. If you have the the time and money. Yeah. To be able to dedicate a year of pre-production. Not even not even. Not even. Just development, man, just that is just straight development. To make make sure you got something tight and you get the interest of the talent, especially, you know, a big name like Brad Pitt. That was huge. And again, they're just enough of a contrast. Uh Edward Norton and Brad Pitt that it once you get that reveal, you're like, huh? Okay, I can see how this guy would make this fantasized version of of that guy. Uh of himself, Fight Club. Fight Club, everybody. One of my favorite films, top 20 list for sure. So, yeah, it was , this was fun to kind of go back in and and look at it again. Watch it again. It really makes me uh again, think about Dr. Jekyll and and Mr. Hyde. Uh towards the end of it. 'Cause Marla even says at one point, you're you're Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Mr. Jackass. Yeah. Mr. Jackass. Yeah. And uh it really is kind of that there really is a strong element of that of that going on with them. Which would be I mean, I don't know. It would be it would be so frightening to fall asleep, wake up days later, and and and have to wonder, oh my goodness, what did my other side do? Or what what has my other side been doing? 'Cause when they have that real honest conversation on the rooftop and he's like, you did this, you know, you you um you know, you but you've got you've got you've got jobs that you're working this and that. And he's like, you can't sleep. That's why you work nine jobs. And then you make candles at night and you, you know, you're having sex with with with Marla and all that. And he's like, you need to take some responsibility. Wow. You created me to do these things that, you know, you were afraid to do or couldn't do. Jekyll and Hyde, you know, Bruce Banner, Incredible Hulk, the same kind of like back and back and forth. That that tortured uh soul. And apparently the cure is just, you know, blown off half your face. And that'll just take care of the psychosis. Not really, not not the answer. But this is a movie. It's a movie, ladies and gentlemen. Which movie did we say that we were going to watch next week? We mentioned staying on the Fincher train and uh making the next stop a visit to The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. I really enjoyed that film. Yes, did I. It's a bummer that they didn't make the ones after that. Money, money, money. And David Fincher likes to burn through money. Yeah, I think yeah, I think Daniel Craig, I think he wanted more. Um Rooney Mara, she may have wanted more too. But yeah, like I think I think I think it really came down to a budget situation. So the Girl with the Dragon Tattoo budget 90 million. That's that's ridiculous. Opening weekend gross domestically 103 million. Okay. Worldwide 233 million. That's a win. 90 million. You turned 233 worldwide. 103 domestic. Maybe Daniel Craig just like, if you want me to work with that crazy director again, I need $28 million. Yeah. Like yeah, I can see Daniel Craig. Crazy American director. Yeah. Yeah, quite quite possibly. 'Cause I remember I remember watching it before and and uh some of the behind the scenes and I mean, they had to work like he like Rooney Mara like she became a smoker. Yeah, we've we've we've chatted about this before. She completely changed. She embodied that character. I enjoyed her version of that of like, I couldn't imagine her being this person at all. Have you watched the the Swedish version? The Swedish? I haven't. So they got a new one now, right? Uh, there were there is yeah, actually the the um actress who's on The Crown on Netflix, who plays Queen Elizabeth is playing this character. But years prior, um there was they they did the whole they did the whole trilogy of of films. It was on Netflix, wasn't it? It was I wish I'd watched them, but they actually they actually not in English. Um but the uh Noomi Rapace. Is that right? Who from Alien Covenant? Yeah. She played the main character. Not from Alien Covenant. From Prometheus. Yeah. She she was the character. Okay. She she was playing her. Okay. Um and a lot of people I remember Scott was talking about. A lot of people hold that a lot of people hold those films in pretty high regard. Some some prefer them to to this Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Um I haven't seen them all all the way through. I think I need to check it out 'cause I actually enjoyed her in Prometheus. So. Mhm. She's talented. And she pulled off the American accent. Yeah. Yeah. She's she's talented and can do a lot of things. She's she's she's an actually there's a show on Netflix now. But but she plays like eight seven or eight different characters. It's like a it's like I want to say it's it's a film. I don't think it's a series. I think it's a film. And one of them like goes missing, but it's like a kind of dystopian future kind of thing. And she's like eight different sisters or clones or something like that. Um yeah, so she's flexing her flexing her chops doing a little bit of um oh, what's Tatiana's show? Uh little black little Orphan Black going on there. Orphan Black? No. No. No. Amazon Prime. Yeah. Oh. Multiple multiple Yeah, you're right. series multiple seasons in. I deleted that one. Like I I think we've seen like three episodes maybe. Mhm. And yeah, it was like, we're not we're done. Yeah. Yeah. I'm sure. Yeah. It's pretty it's pretty pretty layered. Just kind of fell off. Yeah. It happens. We got so much content, right? Too much. Like an embarrassment of riches when it comes to content. I find myself, yeah, having to like pick and choose and trying to trying to stick with something. It can be hard sometimes. To get kind of pulled towards something else. Yeah, it could be tough to stick it out. Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Girl with the Dragon Tattoo it is. All right. All right. We'll be back next week. Fincherland to listen to to talk about The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Until next time. Peace out. Peace.

About Filmmaker Commentary

Reginald Titus Jr.

Apple Spotify YouTube Subscribe Free
Continue Listening

FMC 254 : Scream 7 Directed by Kevin Williamson

November 13, 2026

FMC 253 : It Follows Directed by David Robert Mitchell

November 7, 2026

FMC 252 : Talk to Me Directed by Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou

October 25, 2026

Leave a Response Cancel reply

Never Miss an Episode

New episodes every week — free.

Listen on Spotify Apple Podcasts

Recent Episodes

  • FMC 254 : Scream 7 Directed by Kevin Williamson
  • FMC 253 : It Follows Directed by David Robert Mitchell
  • FMC 252 : Talk to Me Directed by Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou
  • FMC 251 : Weapons Directed by Zachary Michael Cregger

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • November 2025
  • September 2025
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • March 2021
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017

Categories

  • Film
  • Podcast
  • TV
© 2026 Filmmaker Commentary. All rights reserved.
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service